Every ruling, in plain sight
Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.
278 rulings
Rajat Bansal v. Commissioner of Central Goods & Services Tax (CGST)
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Rajat Bansal challenged before the Himachal Pradesh High Court (8 July 2026, CWP No. 11068 of 2025) retrospective cancellation of GST registration from 15 March 2022 by an order dated 17 January 2025, without recording reasons for retrospectivity in either the show-cause notice or the cancellation order. Departmental material indicated that no functioning unit existed at the declared premises for part of the period, but the petitioner contended that backdating still required explicit proposal and reasoning. Under Section 29 and Rules 21 and 22, retrospective effective dates require reasoned adoption and cannot be slipped into the final order silently. The Court set aside the retrospective portion and remanded the matter for a fresh reasoned decision on the appropriate effective date of cancellation; actions taken after 17 January 2025 were left intact. Outcome: assessee-favourable remand. Not legal advice.
Phoenix Medical Syatems (P.) Ltd. v. State of Andhra Pradesh
In favour of the assessee
Phoenix Medical Systems (P.) Ltd. (Writ Petition No. 22371 of 2024) challenged a Section 74 assessment before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh on 8 July 2026. The adjudicating authority did not consider the assessee’s reply and failed to grant mandatory personal hearing under Section 75(4) where an adverse DRC-07 was contemplated. The vitiated order and consequential proceedings were quashed. Outcome favoured the assessee. Sections 74 and 107 frame appeal rights after valid adjudication; defective hearing renders the order a nullity at writ stage. Medical device and pharma distributors facing fraud notices should document hearing requests and replies. Informational; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-08, High Court of Andhra Pradesh recorded in favour of the assessee in WRIT PETITION NO. 22371 OF 2024. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74, CGST S.75, CGST S.107. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
P. Venkataramaniah & Co. v. Assistant Commissioner ST
In favour of the assessee
P. Venkataramaniah & Co., a partnership providing works contract services to government departments, challenged a composite assessment spanning multiple tax periods. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh (Writ Petition No. 2136 of 2025, 8 July 2026) under Sections 73 and 75 set aside the clubbed order as invalid and granted liberty to initiate separate proceedings through period-wise notices. Outcome favoured the assessee. Continues Andhra Pradesh High Court practice invalidating multi-period DRC-07 orders in standard demand cases. Government contractors should expect year-specific SCNs if department revisits assessments. Informational for CA practice; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-08, High Court of Andhra Pradesh recorded in favour of the assessee in WRIT PETITION NO: 2136 OF 2025. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73, CGST S.75. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Friends Alloys v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Friends Alloys filed a writ before the Himachal Pradesh High Court (CWP No. 4997 of 2025, 8 July 2026) challenging an order-in-original and DRC-07 summary instead of filing under Section 107 CGST. Thakur and Sharma JJ held writ was inappropriate where statutory appeal existed under Sections 74 and 107, permitted withdrawal with liberty to appeal within thirty days excluding time spent in writ. Outcome favoured the assessee in obtaining appeal window, not merits. Taxpayers should prefer Section 107; courts may exclude writ period from limitation when redirecting to appellate remedy. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
WFB Baird and Company India (P.) Ltd. v. State Tax Officer I
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
WFB Baird and Company India (P.) Ltd. approached the Madras High Court in WP Nos. 24237 and 24239 of 2026, decided 7 July 2026, against a demand raised under section 74 of the CGST Act for alleged excess input tax credit from return mismatches. The show cause notice did not allege fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts. Justice Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy held that without ingredients required for section 74, proceedings must run under section 73, rendering the assessment order unsustainable. The matter was remanded for a fresh decision under the correct section, with liberty to claim applicable statutory reliefs including those under section 128A where relevant. The outcome favoured the assessee with remand. Useful for distinguishing section 73 versus 74 in ITC mismatch cases. Not legal advice.
Shree Ganesh Infra v. State of U.P
In favour of the assessee
Shree Ganesh Infra (Writ Tax No. 1728 of 2025) quashed demand proceedings before the High Court of Allahabad on 7 July 2026. After GST registration cancellation and business discontinuance, show cause notice was served only by upload on the GST portal; Section 169 service mechanics could not oblige a cancelled registrant to monitor the portal. Service breached natural justice under Sections 73, 75, and 169. The demand order fell with the defective notice. Outcome favoured the assessee. Cancelled registrants remain persons under law but portal-only service post-cancellation is risky for department. Alternative service modes may be required. Informational; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-07, High Court of Allahabad recorded in favour of the assessee in WRIT TAX NO. 1728 OF 2025. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.75, CGST S.73, CGST S.169. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Mohammed Kamran v. Senior Intelligence Officer Directorate General of Goods and Service Tax Intelligence
In favour of the revenue
Mohammed Kamran, a scrap trader, challenged parallel GST investigations before the High Court of Karnataka (Writ Petition No. 38771 of 2025, decided 7 July 2026). State GST had initiated an inquiry into discrepancies in his transactions; during its pendency the Directorate General of GST Intelligence commenced a wider investigation into related supply chains, and the state inquiry was formally transferred to the central authority. The petitioner invoked Section 6 of the CGST Act to argue that dual proceedings were barred. The court examined Sections 6, 69, 132, and 168 and found no identical liability or overlapping adjudication on the same cause of action. The designated central authority was competent to proceed on its own investigative material. Parallel investigation was held permissible. The writ was dismissed in favour of the revenue. This summary is for professional reference on officer jurisdiction, not legal advice.
Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. v. Karnataka Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling
In favour of the revenue
Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. filed Writ Petition No. 192 of 2022 before the Karnataka High Court (7 July 2026) challenging an advance ruling given to another entity on GST classification or rate for metro-related works. Under Sections 101 and 103 CGST, AAR and AAAR rulings bind only the applicant and its jurisdictional officers; Article 226 does not allow third parties to rewrite outcomes. The petitioner lacked locus where its contract with the applicant did not embed specific GST classification or rate terms, so no direct civil consequence arose. The writ was dismissed in favour of revenue’s stand on maintainability. Contracting parties should negotiate explicit tax clauses rather than rely on another’s ruling. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
Ashok Parakh v. State of West Bengal
In favour of the assessee
Ashok Parakh filed a writ before the Calcutta High Court (WPA 2425/2025, 7 July 2026) against ex parte assessment and appellate orders arising after notices and orders were uploaded only under the "Additional Notices/Orders" tab, allegedly due to a GSTN tabulation glitch of which the network was aware. Sections 169 and 73 CGST framed the service dispute. Justice Kausik Chanda held the petitioner could not be saddled with ex parte assessment when communications never appeared in the primary notices section, breaching natural justice. Assessment and appellate orders were set aside with liberty to the revenue to issue fresh notice properly. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. The case is significant for West Bengal GST practice where systemic portal categorization errors have repeatedly led courts to quash demands until valid, visible service is effected.
Parsam Traders v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax
Parsam Traders (Writ Petition No. 2577 of 2023) obtained relief from the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati on 6 July 2026. The Assistant Commissioner passed a common assessment order for 2018-19, 2019-20, and 2020-21 under CGST and APGST, clubbing periods contrary to established Division Bench precedent. The court set aside the composite and related unsigned orders without merits examination, directed separate notices per period, and required the petitioner to deposit 20% of disputed tax within eight weeks given the 2022 assessment date. Outcome favoured the assessee on procedure. Unsigned orders and composite periods remain fatal flaws in this forum. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-06, the High Court recorded as recorded in the order in the writ petition. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.75. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Ind-korosho Exim v. State Tax Officer-2
In favour of the revenue
Ind-korosho Exim challenged a penalty order before the High Court of Madras (WP No. 21615 of 2026, decided 6 July 2026) for alleged non-maintenance of records under Section 122 of the CGST Act. The petitioner argued that Section 47 prevented penalty once late fee was levied for related defaults. Section 47 deals specifically with belated filing of returns; Section 122 covers multiple compliance failures including non-maintenance of books under Sections 35 and 36. The court found no statutory overlap barring a distinct penalty for record-keeping failures separate from return delays. The impugned order disclosed no jurisdictional or legal infirmity warranting writ interference under Article 226. The petition was dismissed in favour of the State Tax Officer. Practitioners should distinguish return-filing defaults from independent Section 122 breaches.
DG Anti Profiteering v. Emaar India Ltd
In favour of the revenue
The GST Appellate Tribunal (NAPA No. 153 (PB) of 2025, 6 July 2026) addressed methodology in DGAP proceedings against Emaar India Ltd. under Section 171 CGST and Rules 126 and 133. For residential projects, the Tribunal validated computing ITC benefit using pre-GST and post-GST credit-to-cost ratios at project level, with area-wise allocation among units. It stressed that the benefit must accrue uniformly to all similarly placed buyers and cannot be restricted to amounts received from individual purchasers. This clarifies how profiteering amounts are spread across a project when rate or ITC changes occur. Outcome favoured revenue on methodological points relevant to quantification. Developers and CAs auditing pass-through should apply consistent project-wide allocation rather than buyer-by-buyer caps. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
Bhardwaj Construction v. Union of India
See the decision
M/s. Bhardwaj Construction filed CWJC No. 4763 of 2026 before the Patna High Court, decided 6 July 2026, against a section 73 BGST order disallowing input tax credit as beyond section 16(4) time limits, with recovery enforced years later. The assessee invoked retrospective sections 16(5) and 16(6) via Finance (2) Act 2024 and Circular No. 237/31/2024-GST paragraph 3.5, permitting rectification where no appeal was filed against the demand order. The Court declined writ quashing but granted liberty to file section 148 rectification within one month, with hearing and reasoned order within three months. Writ disposed accordingly. Appropriate route for time-bar ITC disputes post-circular. Not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment and current notifications before advising clients on compliance steps.
Siva Electricals v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax
In favour of the assessee
Siva Electricals (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 17618 of 2026, 3 July 2026) faced best-judgment assessment under Section 62 for failure to furnish GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B within statutory timelines under Section 39. Subsequently petitioner filed returns and paid tax, interest and late fee, albeit beyond thirty-day window referenced in Section 62 scheme. Revenue sought to pursue recovery under assessment despite compliance. Court applied Section 62(2): once valid returns and tax paid, assessment deemed withdrawn and recovery cannot continue on basis of superseded Section 62 order. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Late compliance preserves relief from best-judgment demand though interest and late fee remain payable. Informational summary. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.
SDE Engineers Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer
In favour of the assessee
SDE Engineers Ltd. pursued T.R.E.V.C. No. 52 of 2008 before the Telangana High Court; judgment 3 July 2026 (pre-GST sales tax). The assessee leased tech-park premises with amenities and furniture to IT companies under composite agreements described as permission to use without transfer of possession or exclusive control; common facilities were shared. The Commercial Tax Officer treated receipts as taxable transfer of right to use goods. The court held no TRUG occurred; consideration arose from service-style permission to use space and facilities, not a sale of goods under VAT Section 4. Orders annulling tax were restored; outcome for assessee. Article 366 definitions informed analysis. Useful historical precedent for composite lease structuring. Not legal advice. Modern co-working and fitted-office leases may analogise to this permission-to-use analysis when assessing legacy VAT exposure.
Hansraj Gurjar v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
Hansraj Gurjar filed a second bail application in S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous 2nd Bail Application No. 8382 of 2026 before the Rajasthan High Court; order 3 July 2026. He was arrested for allegedly operating fake firms and facilitating GST evasion under Section 132. He sought parity with a co-accused granted bail. The court noted no substantial change in circumstances and that his role was distinct and more serious. Economic offences warrant strict scrutiny under BNSS Section 483; parity alone did not justify release. Second bail application dismissed; outcome aligns with prosecution. Summary for understanding bail standards in Section 132 cases; not legal advice. Accused persons in layered fake-firm schemes should expect courts to scrutinise role, prior bail history and gravity before granting parity.
Susanta Kumar Lenka v. Joint Commissioner, State Tax (Appeal)
In favour of the revenue
Susanta Kumar Lenka (Orissa High Court, WP(C) 16755 of 2026, 2 July 2026) challenged both the original GST adjudication and the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) order, alleging non-application of mind at the first appellate stage. With the GST Appellate Tribunal operational and Finance Ministry notification prescribing appeal windows under Section 112 coupled with Section 109 machinery, the High Court declined writ intervention. Factual disputes about whether the appellate authority adequately dealt with submissions were held better suited for tribunal scrutiny following statutory deposit compliance. Continuing the writ would effectively bypass GSTAT’s fact-finding role. Petitioner must pursue prescribed appellate channels. Outcome: in favour of the revenue. The judgment illustrates post-2024 High Court reluctance to entertain writs where GSTAT remedy is available for merit-based grievances against adjudication and first appeal. Informational summary only.
Silver Castle Holidays and Resorts (India) (P.) Ltd. v. Superintendent, Central Tax and Central Excise Department
In favour of the assessee
Silver Castle Holidays and Resorts (India) (P.) Ltd. filed WP(C) No. 41806 of 2025 before the Kerala High Court; decision 2 July 2026. The Superintendent, Central Tax denied input tax credit for April 2018 through March 2019, citing belated filing of returns under Section 16(4). The company showed that returns for the relevant months were in fact filed within the relaxation period prescribed by Section 16(5). Where the extended deadline applies, denial based only on the original Section 16(4) bar is inconsistent with the amended law. The court set aside the denial and held the assessee entitled to ITC if otherwise eligible on merits. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Section 16 was the focal provision. Summary for CAs tracking post-amendment ITC timelines; not legal advice.
Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. filed a writ before the High Court of Orissa (W.P.(C) No. 17093 of 2025, decided 2 July 2026) challenging recovery and denial of accumulated input tax credit refund following retrospective amendment of Rule 89(5) of the CGST Rules. The assessee sought direct high court relief; revenue relied on departmental circulars suggesting no useful appeal lay. Under Sections 54 and 112, the court held the GST Appellate Tribunal could adjudicate facts and law independently and circulars did not render statutory appeal futile. The writ was dismissed with liberty to file appeal before GSTAT. Outcome favoured the revenue on forum selection, without finally deciding refund entitlement on merits. This editorial summary is not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment for exact findings.
Narasus Diary v. Deputy State Tax Officer II
See the decision
M/s Narasus Diary (Madras High Court, WP 21857 of 2026, 2 July 2026, Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy, J.) challenged Section 62 best-judgment assessment (Form GST ASMT-13 / DRC-07 dated 20 October 2022) for June 2022 following registration cancellation under Section 29 for non-filing of GSTR-3B. Petitioner explained delayed approach because registration was cancelled on 15 March 2023 before awareness of order. Critically, belated GSTR-3B for June 2022 disclosed tax paid exceeding Section 62 determination. Government counsel acknowledged return data. Court held reassessment necessary in interest of justice; impugned order set aside and remanded to Deputy State Tax Officer II, Salem, to pass fresh order within three months after hearing. Outcome: effectively in assessee’s favour; matter remanded. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.