Every ruling, in plain sight

Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.

278 rulings

High Court of KarnatakaAppellate Authority

Aditya Security Force v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (AUDIT 2)

In favour of the assessee

Aditya Security Force challenged ex parte GST orders before the Karnataka High Court (Writ Petition No. 105019 of 2026, 22 June 2026), raising arguable issues on reverse charge liability and demand exceeding the show cause notice under Sections 73 and 107 CGST. In the peculiar facts, including ex parte adjudication, the Court allowed a belated statutory appeal to be filed for merits adjudication rather than deciding tax issues in writ. Outcome favoured the assessee procedurally with remand to the appellate forum. Assessees with credible limitation and merit arguments may obtain liberty to appeal after ex parte orders, subject to court discretion. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107CGST S.73
High CourtInput Tax Credit

24 HRS Productions v. Superintendent of GST and Central Excise

M/s. 24 HRS Productions filed W.P. No. 11123 of 2026 before the Madras High Court; the court disposed of the matter on 24 March 2026 (case metadata records 22 June 2026). The assessee challenged an ex parte order dated 29 April 2024 under section 73 following Show Cause Notice No. 62/2023 after failing to file a reply or attend personal hearing. Statutory appeal limitation had long expired. By consent, the Court remanded for de novo adjudication on merits if the assessee pre-deposits fifty per cent of disputed tax within thirty days, files a substantive reply treating the impugned order as addendum to the SCN, and meets other conditions; bank attachment would vacate on compliance. Section 16 ITC eligibility may be re-examined on merits. Not legal advice.

CGST S.16
High Court of TelanganaAppellate Authority

Ravi Kunchepu v. State Tax Officer (FAC)

See the decision

Ravi Kunchepu approached the Telangana High Court (WP 18708 of 2026, 18 June 2026) by writ against an order under Section 73 of the CGST Act, contending he became aware of it only when it appeared under “additional notices” on the GST portal. The issue was whether writ jurisdiction should substitute for the statutory appellate route. The court declined to entertain the writ where an appeal under Section 107 remained available, treating the dispute as one fit for the appellate hierarchy rather than exceptional writ interference. Petitioner was granted liberty to file the statutory appeal, with direction that the appellate authority consider condonation of delay, the mandatory pre-deposit, and decide on merits if sufficient cause was established. This preserves the primacy of Section 107 while accommodating portal-based service concerns through the condonation mechanism rather than bypassing appeal.

CGST S.107CGST S.73
High Court of MadrasReturns

Assistant Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise v. Akshaya Building Solution

In favour of the assessee

In a writ appeal before the Madras High Court (18 June 2026, W.A. No. 3577 of 2024), Akshaya Building Solution sought rectification of clerical and arithmetical errors in GSTR-1 for early GST periods so that outward supply details and input tax credit would flow correctly to its customers’ ledgers. The Assistant Commissioner resisted on grounds of delay and because the portal did not permit online amendment for those periods. Under Section 39 and Rule 59, the appellate bench held rectification of genuine clerical and arithmetical mistakes could not be denied merely on delay or transient portal limitations when the error frustrated the statutory chain of ITC. Corrected returns or manual rectification as permitted by law had to be allowed. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Important for legacy return correction and ITC pass-through in construction supplies. Not legal advice.

CGST S.39CGST Rules R.59
High Court of GauhatiRegistration

Smt. Sunita Rai v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Smt. Sunita Rai, engaged in supplying vehicles on hire, challenged before the Gauhati High Court (17 June 2026, WP (C) No. 3165 of 2026) cancellation of GST registration for non-filing of returns based on a show-cause notice that did not specify the period of default and a cancellation order that recorded no specific reasons linking facts to Section 29. The petitioner argued that she could not effectively respond without knowing which tax periods were in default. Under Section 29 and Rule 22, adverse civil consequences require a speaking order and adequate notice so the assessee can meet the case against it. The Court quashed the cancellation and remanded the matter to the proper officer for fresh consideration after issuing a compliant notice and passing a reasoned order. Outcome: assessee-favourable remand. Emphasizes reasoned orders in registration cancellation. Not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST Rules R.22
High Court of MadrasPenalty

Sai Cashew Processors v. Deputy State Tax Officer -1

In favour of the assessee

Sai Cashew Processors challenged combined late fee and penalty before the High Court of Madras (WP Nos. 21603, 21609 and 21622 of 2026, decided 17 June 2026) for delayed filing of GST returns. Revenue imposed statutory late fee under Section 47 and an additional general penalty under Section 125 for the identical default. The court held that once a specific late fee is prescribed and levied for belated returns, a general penalty for the same default is unwarranted and amounts to impermissible double punishment under the scheme of the Act. Penalty orders were set aside while late fee collections remained intact. The decision favoured the assessee and aligns with Madras High Court jurisprudence on the interaction of Sections 47 and 125 for return delays.

CGST S.125CGST S.47
High CourtDemands Adjudication

MS Sarada Refrigeration and Air Condition v. State of Assam

MS Sarada Refrigeration and Air Condition (WP(C) No. 2345 of 2026) prevailed before the Gauhati High Court on 17 June 2026. The proper officer had passed an order in original under Section 73(9) after issuing only a summary show cause notice in Form DRC-01, without a substantive notice under Section 73(1) detailing cause of action. Following Construction Catalysers Pvt. Ltd., the court quashed the order dated 8 March 2024 and directed issuance of a proper Section 73(1) notice dating back to the summary notice, with limitation under Section 73(10) excluded for the interim period. Outcome favoured the assessee. Rule 142 summaries cannot replace full show cause notices. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-06-17, the High Court recorded as recorded in the order in the writ petition. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.73
High Court of GujaratPenalty

Manoj Ramkishan Agrawal v. Union of India

In favour of the revenue

Partners of a trading firm challenged penalty under Section 122 before the High Court of Gujarat (R/Special Civil Application No. 7965 of 2026, decided 17 June 2026). Revenue found complicity in generating fake invoices and e-way bills without actual supply, with admissions and forensic evidence linking the petitioners to hawala operations and cash returns. Section 90 on liability of partners was also relevant. The court held that knowledge and consent of the partners was established on the record, justifying penalty under Section 122 against persons who caused the violation. No breach of natural justice was demonstrated in the adjudication. Writ interference was declined and the outcome favoured the Union of India. The decision underscores personal penalty exposure of partners in bogus-invoice and circular-trading schemes detected by intelligence authorities.

CGST S.122CGST S.90
High Court of MadrasInterest Waiver

Jayashree Enterprises v. Assistant Commissioner (ST)

In favour of the revenue

Jayashree Enterprises filed WP No. 19835 of 2026 before the Madras High Court; judgment 17 June 2026. The department found ineligible input tax credit availed and utilised where declared ITC in GSTR-3B exceeded credits appearing in GSTR-2A. It imposed interest at twenty-four per cent from the date of utilisation until reversal, under the specific provision read with Rule 88B, rather than general Section 50 interest. The assessee argued cash payment later avoided utilisation-based interest. The court upheld the order: utilisation through the electronic credit ledger triggers the enhanced rate regardless of subsequent cash adjustment. Outcome: in favour of revenue. Section 50 contrasted with the special rule for ineligible credit. Summary for ITC reconciliation risk; not legal advice. Taxpayers should reverse ineligible ITC promptly to limit the utilisation-period interest exposure highlighted in this ruling.

CGST S.50CGST Rules R.88B
High CourtRecovery Attachment

Sultan Mahmood Khan v. Commercial Tax Officer

Sultan Mahmood Khan, proprietor of M/s I N Enterprises, filed a writ before the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru (WP No. 11328 of 2026, decided 16 June 2026) against provisional attachment of his ICICI bank account under Section 83 of the CGST Act in Form GST DRC-22 dated 2 May 2024. The attachment had continued beyond the one-year limit prescribed in Section 83(2). Following the Supreme Court in Kesari Nandan Mobile, the court held the order lapsed by operation of law; revenue cannot renew or reissue provisional attachment for the same cause after lapse. Taxpayers need not routinely approach High Courts to enforce the statutory cap when revenue fails to lift attachment. The petition was allowed; the petitioner could operate the account unless other proceedings applied.

CGST S.83
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

Siri Constructions v. Assistant Commissionerst

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Siri Constructions (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 26667 of 2025, 16 June 2026) challenged summary assessment in Form GST DRC-07 where department admitted absence of assessing officer signature. Under Section 160 CGST Act, authentication is essential; unsigned summaries cannot create enforceable demand even if visible on portal dashboards. Curative provisions cannot ratify void assessment. Court set aside impugned DRC-07 solely for signature defect without expressing views on substantive tax issues, preserving open questions for fresh adjudication. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded for compliant order. Reinforces procedural checklist before conceding demand or filing appeal. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice. Material facts and holdings are drawn from the reported judgment.

CGST S.160
High Court of KarnatakaRegistration

Pristine Steels v. Superintendent of Central Tax

In favour of the assessee

The Karnataka High Court (16 June 2026, Writ Petition No. 17566 of 2026) set aside cancellation of Pristine Steels’ registration where the show-cause notice was vague, lacked material particulars linking the assessee to alleged non-compliance, and the proper officer ignored the petitioner’s detailed reply filed within time. The writ raised whether cancellation under Section 29 could proceed when the taxpayer had not been told precisely what facts were disputed. Rule 22 requires detailed grounds in Form GST REG-17 and a meaningful opportunity to respond before registration is cancelled. Where the authority neither engaged with the reply nor recorded reasons for rejecting it, cancellation was unsustainable. The SCN and cancellation order were quashed with liberty for fresh proceedings strictly in accordance with law. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Reinforces that registration cancellation must be evidence-based and responsive to representations. Editorial summary for CAs; not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST Rules R.22
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

Marella Siva Narayana v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax

In favour of the assessee

Marella Siva Narayana (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 13473 of 2026, 16 June 2026) disputed state GST assessment for specified tax periods where Form GST DRC-07 lacked assessing officer signature, an fact admitted by revenue. Signature requirement under Section 160 read with Rule 26 is mandatory for valid assessment; neither curative statutes nor electronic service under portal workflows salvage unsigned orders because they never validly came into existence. Petitioner approached court without undue delay once defect discovered. Impugned order set aside; assessing officer may pass fresh signed assessment after show cause and hearing. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Part of consistent AP High Court jurisprudence protecting taxpayers from procedurally infirm DRC-07 summaries. Editorial summary only. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.160CGST Rules R.26
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

AMR Vision v. Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax

In favour of the assessee

AMR Vision (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 10393 of 2025, 16 June 2026, R. Raghunandan Rao and T.C.D. Sekhar, JJ.) challenged a demand crystallized in Form GST DRC-07 for lacking the Assessing Officer’s signature. Both petitioner and State conceded the omission. Under Section 160 of the CGST Act and Rule 26 of the CGST Rules, assessment orders require proper authentication; unsigned orders are void ab initio for assessment purposes. Section 169 service mechanics cannot cure absent signature because defect goes to existence of valid order, not merely mode of communication. Delay in filing writ was irrelevant. Impugned assessment set aside with liberty for fresh proceeding after notice. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Andhra Pradesh line of authority treats unsigned DRC-07 as recurring procedural vulnerability auditors should verify. Not legal advice.

CGST S.160CGST S.169CGST Rules R.26
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

Nominee Works Committee Kalavalla v. Deputy Assistant Commissioner STII

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Nominee Works Committee Kalavalla (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 7693 of 2026, 15 June 2026) received GST assessment served electronically without assessing officer signature on DRC-07. Applying precedent on Section 160 and Section 169, court found patent irregularity invalidating order irrespective of portal delivery. Writ entertained subject to twenty per cent pre-deposit of disputed demand balancing revenue safeguard. Impugned assessment quashed; Deputy Assistant Commissioner (ST-II) directed to adjudicate afresh after notice and hearing, issuing duly signed order. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Committees and associations registered under GST should verify signature and DIN on every DRC-07 before paying or appealing. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice. Material facts and holdings are drawn from the reported judgment.

CGST S.160CGST S.169
High Court of KarnatakaRegistration

Mahadevappa v. Principal Chief Commissioner of Central Tax

In favour of the revenue

Mahadevappa’s writ before the Karnataka High Court (15 June 2026, Writ Petition No. 102663 of 2026) arose from suspension and cancellation of GST registration at premises owned by his wife, following her complaint over use of a registered general power of attorney. The petitioner sought Article 226 relief to restore registration and bypass departmental and appellate proceedings. The Court held that a domestic dispute over authority to operate from the premises did not displace the statutory registration and appeal mechanism under Sections 29, 30 and 75 of the CGST Act. Where Section 107 provides an effective appellate remedy against cancellation, high courts ordinarily refrain from exercising writ jurisdiction at the threshold unless exceptional circumstances exist, which were not made out on the facts pleaded. Writ jurisdiction was therefore declined. Outcome: in favour of the revenue—the petitioner must pursue remedies under the CGST Act including appeal and revocation pathways. Summary for practitioners on alternate remedy and writ maintainability; not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST S.30CGST S.75Constitution Art.226
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

GSN Granites v. Assistant Commissioner ST

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

GSN Granites (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 14368 of 2026, 15 June 2026) impugned assessment communicated only via GST portal where Form GST DRC-07 bore no assessing officer signature. Following binding precedent under Section 160 and Rule 26, unsigned orders cannot operate as valid assessments; curative provisions in Sections 160 and 169 do not validate them retrospectively. Writ jurisdiction was exercised conditional on deposit of twenty per cent of disputed tax, balancing revenue protection with procedural rectification. Impugned order quashed; matter remanded to Assistant Commissioner (ST) for fresh adjudication after personal hearing. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Practitioners should secure signed copies and not rely solely on portal thumbnails. Informational summary for Chartered Universe. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.160CGST S.169CGST Rules R.26
High Court of TelanganaDemands Adjudication

B.K. Steels v. Assistant Commissioner (State Tax)

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

B.K. Steels (Telangana High Court, WP 17499 of 2026, 15 June 2026) returned after earlier writ remand directing adjudication on original show cause under Sections 74 and 75 following personal-hearing violation. Despite directions, Assessing Officer issued second show cause and fresh order for same year, effectively restarting proceedings. Court held second notice impermissible and beyond remand scope; authority must adjudicate first show cause only after granting compliant hearing and considering reply. Impugned order set aside with consequential directions preserving prior High Court mandate. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Important for litigation strategy after partial writ wins—department must adhere strictly to remand terms. Not legal advice. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.74CGST S.75
High Court of ChhattisgarhArrest Bail

Aman Singh v. Director General Goods and Service Tax Intelligence

In favour of the assessee

Aman Singh applied for regular bail (MCRC 3019 of 2026, Chhattisgarh High Court, 15 June 2026) in a DG GST Intelligence investigation alleging creation and operation of a firm to pass fraudulent input tax credit using bogus suppliers and invoices, grounded in statements, banking trails and operational links under Sections 69 and 132 of the CGST Act (procedure under BNSS Section 483). Prosecution argued custodial interrogation remained necessary; defence highlighted absence of unimpeachable proof identifying applicant as proprietor and substantial progress of investigation without further detention. The court balanced coercive needs against prolonged incarceration where evidence was largely documentary and already secured. Extended custody and custodial interrogation were not warranted; regular bail granted subject to conditions including cooperation. Outcome: in favour of the assessee/applicant. Bail jurisprudence in GST fraud matters turns on tampering risk, flight, and necessity of custody—not maximum sentence alone. Not legal advice.

CGST S.69CGST S.132BNSS S.483
High Court of MadrasInput Tax Credit

Tvl. Fathima Traders v. Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Chennai

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Tvl. Fathima Traders filed WP Nos. 22419, 22420 and 22422 of 2023 before the Madras High Court; ruling 12 June 2026. Input tax credit was denied because a supplier’s GST registration was cancelled with retrospective effect, even though the supplier was active and registered when most supplies occurred and transactions largely predated the cancellation order. The court held that retrospective cancellation alone, without examining whether supplies were genuine and supported under Rule 36, cannot justify wholesale ITC rejection. The matter was remanded to the assessing authority for reconsideration after granting the petitioner a reasonable opportunity of hearing. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. Sections 16 and 29 were engaged. Summary for supply-chain due diligence; not legal advice. The remand ensures verification of invoices, tax payments and business nexus rather than a mechanical denial tied only to supplier registration status.

CGST S.16CGST S.29CGST Rules R.36