Every ruling, in plain sight
Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.
278 rulings
Madhu Sudan Periwal v. State of Bihar
In favour of the revenue
Madhu Sudan Periwal, a medicine trader, failed to file returns for 2020-21 and was assessed for tax and late fee after show cause notice. The High Court of Patna (Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 8387 of 2026, 15 July 2026) upheld demand of late fee through assessment under Section 73 read with Section 47 of the CGST Act as a statutory mandate. The writ challenging the department’s competence to recover late fee in such proceedings was dismissed as devoid of merit. Outcome favoured the revenue. For return-defaulters, late fee under Section 47 remains enforceable alongside tax determination in Section 73 adjudication. Assessees should file belated returns and fee payments promptly to limit exposure. Informational; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-15, High Court of Patna recorded in favour of the revenue in CIVIL WRIT JURISDICTION CASE NO. 8387 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73, CGST S.47. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Kamlesh Kumar v. State Tax Officer
In favour of the assessee
Kamlesh Kumar challenged detention of a vehicle carrying aluminium roofing sheets before the Uttarakhand High Court in Writ Petition (M/S) No. 3268 of 2023, decided 15 July 2026. Tax officials intercepted the consignment and noted truncated e-way bill numbers on invoices; the assessee explained the discrepancy as a clerical error and demonstrated that goods matched declared documents with no evidence of evasion or undue benefit. Under sections 129, 68, and 125 of the CGST Act, the Court held the penalty order could not be sustained on these facts and directed refund after applicable deduction in line with CBIC circular dated 14 September 2018. The outcome favoured the assessee. The case illustrates how documentation errors in transit may be treated when goods and records align. Not legal advice.
Kagga Pandu Ranga Rao v. Assistant Commissioner ST
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Kagga Pandu Ranga Rao (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 19153 of 2026, 15 July 2026, Ninla Jayasurya and T.C.D. Sekhar, JJ.) attacked assessment orders uploaded without Document Identification Number despite mandatory CBIC circular requirements traceable to Section 168 compliance culture. Missing DIN rendered order non est; uploading on portal could not substitute statutory identification and authentication discipline under Section 160. Assessee demonstrated prejudice because unidentified orders complicate appellate and compliance tracking. Court set aside impugned assessment and permitted authorities to pass fresh order after due notice, assignment of DIN, and hearing. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Reinforces DIN hygiene alongside signature requirements in Andhra Pradesh GST litigation. Not legal advice. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.
Zach Rubber (P.) Ltd. v. State Tax Officer
In favour of the assessee
Zach Rubber (P.) Ltd. filed WP(C) No. 20131 of 2026 before the Kerala High Court; judgment 14 July 2026. The State Tax Officer denied input tax credit after the company filed its March 2020 return on 17 November 2020, treating the claim as barred under Section 16(4). The assessee relied on Section 16(5), which permits ITC where the return for the period is filed on or before 30 November 2021, and on Section 168A where relevant for timeline computation. The court held rejection as purely time-barred was unsustainable and directed reconsideration if the assessee was otherwise eligible. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. This aligns with other High Courts on post-amendment ITC relief. Not legal advice. Officers must apply Section 16(5) prospectively to March 2020 and similar periods when returns precede the November 2021 cutoff.
Vindhya Spinning Mills (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise
In favour of the assessee
Vindhya Spinning Mills (P) Ltd. filed a writ before the High Court of Madras (W.P.(MD) Nos. 16757 & 16758 of 2025, decided 14 July 2026) for refund of accumulated input tax credit under inverted duty structure. The manufacturer of combed cotton yarn used certain inputs taxed at higher rates than the output. Refund under Section 54 read with Rule 89 was rejected because the principal input matched the output rate. Under Section 168, the court held the statute allows refund if any input attracts higher GST than output; a circular restricting refund to non-principal inputs was unconstitutional. Refund with interest was directed. Outcome favoured the assessee on inverted duty refund eligibility. This editorial summary is not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment for exact findings.
Vikas Kumar Omar v. Principal Commissioner of CGST Commissionerate at Rohtak
In favour of the assessee
Vikas Kumar Omar filed a writ before the High Court of Punjab & Haryana (decided 14 July 2026) against penalty imposed under Sections 122 and 126 of the CGST Act without issuance of a prior show cause notice and without affording reasonable opportunity of being heard. Non-compliance with the statutory mandate of natural justice in penalty proceedings vitiated the impugned order ab initio. Section 126 requires consideration of mitigating factors only after proper adjudicatory process is followed. The court quashed the unsustainable penalty. The outcome favoured the assessee. Penalty under the CGST framework cannot be imposed without SCN and a fair hearing, regardless of the strength of the revenue's underlying allegations on bogus credits or invoices. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
Eclipse Hospitality LLP (Earlier known as Viralminda Properties LLP) v. Superintendent of Central Excise GST Range I Adyar Division Chennai South
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Eclipse Hospitality LLP approached the Madras High Court (14 July 2026, WP No. 25429 of 2026) after its fresh registration application was rejected because returns for the period up to the earlier cancellation date had not been filed once the normal due dates had passed and no extension notification existed. The forum had to decide whether a new registrant could be compelled to file returns for periods when it was not registered and filing was practically impossible. Applying Sections 25 and 37 and Rule 9, the Court held the rejection unsustainable as it demanded an impossible act. The matter was remanded: authorities must reconsider the registration application if remaining conditions are satisfied. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. Useful for CAs advising on re-registration after cancellation. Not legal advice.
Karamsar Poultry Appliances v. Assistant Commissioner, Janakpuri Division, CGST Delhi West
In favour of the revenue
Karamsar Poultry Appliances filed a writ before the High Court of Delhi (decided 13 July 2026) seeking immediate refund of unutilised input tax credit under Section 54. A show cause notice proposed partial rejection; an order in original partially sanctioned refund while rejecting the balance; the appellate authority set aside wrongful rejection without mandating unconditional release or foreclosing further revenue examination. A subsequent order again rejected refund. The court held the proper course was statutory appeal under Sections 107 and 121 to test the reasons and scope of the appellate order—not repeated writ petitions at each administrative stage. The petition was dismissed in favour of the revenue on maintainability grounds. This editorial summary is not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment for exact findings.
Mahalaxmi Industries v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
Mahalaxmi Industries petitioned the Gujarat High Court (Special Civil Application No. 9118 of 2026, 10 July 2026) against a fake ITC demand order sharing the same SCN and modus operandi as a connected entity at the same address. Supehia and Nanavati JJ held an effective remedy under Sections 74 and 107 CGST existed and writ under Article 226 was not maintainable. The writ was rejected in favour of appellate process. Outcome favoured revenue on forum. Connected-party cases still require statutory appeals unless exceptional jurisdictional defects are shown. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
M S Enterprises v. Commissioner, Central Goods and Services Tax
In favour of the assessee
M S Enterprises approached the Punjab & Haryana High Court (10 July 2026, CWP No. 20679 of 2026) against retrospective cancellation of GST registration from 1 May 2023 when the show-cause notice had not proposed that effective date. The assessee contended that it was never given an opportunity to answer a proposal to cancel registration with effect from a date more than two years before the order. Under Section 29 and Rule 22, cancellation must align with the case made in the SCN; retrospective effect requires explicit proposal, supporting material and reasoning in both notice and order. An officer cannot insert a backdated effective date at the final stage without prior intimation. Citing precedent from this Court and other High Courts, the bench set aside the cancellation order as unsustainable while preserving the department’s liberty to issue a fresh SCN and proceed lawfully if grounds exist. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. For CAs, the case illustrates limits on backdated registration cancellation without notice. Not legal advice.
Indian Wire Products Company, In re
In favour of the revenue
On appeal, the West Bengal Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling (Appeal Case No. 02/WBAAAR/APPEAL/2026, 10 July 2026) considered Indian Wire Products Company’s restaurant model involving supply of tobacco-based and herbal hookah flavours through hookah apparatus alongside food and beverages. The issue was whether such supplies were composite restaurant service under paragraph 6(b) of Schedule II and Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate), or separate supplies of goods. The AAAR held that merely bundling hookah flavours with restaurant facilities did not bring those flavour supplies within the restaurant service entry; they remained supplies of goods to be classified and rated under applicable goods notifications, with Sections 7, 8 and 9 CGST governing scope and levy. Outcome favoured revenue’s characterisation as non-restaurant service supplies. Operators mixing hookah retail with dining should treat flavour supplies as goods unless facts differ materially.
Venus Infra Projects v. Assistant Commissioner of ST
In favour of the revenue
Venus Infra Projects filed W.P. No. 21371 of 2026 before the Madras High Court; decision 9 July 2026. The petitioner’s GST registration was cancelled and later revived; it then sought input tax credit while filing pending returns, invoking Section 16(6). The Assistant Commissioner denied credit. The court interpreted Section 16(6) as conditional: revival allows credit only if Section 16(4) did not already bar it on the date of cancellation. Here the assessee was time-barred under Section 16(4) when registration was cancelled, so subsequent revival could not revive lost ITC. Writ dismissed; outcome in favour of revenue. Sections 16, 29, 30 and 39 together govern cancellation and credit. Summary for registration-compliance planning; not legal advice. The decision warns infra contractors that delayed returns before cancellation can permanently foreclose ITC even after registration revival.
Sunil Chauhan Prop of Shree Chem India v. Principal Commissioner of CGST, Delhi North
In favour of the revenue
Sunil Chauhan, proprietor of Shree Chem India, challenged adjudication before the High Court of Delhi (W.P.(C) No. 8412 of 2026, decided 9 July 2026). A show cause notice under Section 74 alleged mis-declaration, undervaluation, and clandestine clearance of agro-chemical products, proposing demand of tax, interest, and multiple penalties including under Section 122. The petitioner argued penalties required separate proceedings from tax adjudication. The court held that the proper officer adjudicating tax liability from the same notice is competent to impose all consequential penalties in one integrated proceeding; Rule 142 does not mandate split adjudications. No jurisdictional error was found. The writ was dismissed in favour of the Principal Commissioner of CGST, Delhi North. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
State of Tamil Nadu v. I. Vetrivel
In favour of the revenue
The State of Tamil Nadu filed tax revision petitions in TCR(MD) Nos. 23–30 of 2024 before the Madras High Court; decision 9 July 2026. The dispute concerned purchase tax under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act and TN VAT on sand, gravel and jelly bought from unregistered dealers for use in works contracts. A Constitution Bench precedent supports such levy on goods not previously tax-suffered. The first appellate authority and Tribunal had annulled assessments; the High Court found those orders perverse and restored purchase tax under Section 7-A, holding it operates independently of Section 3-B on transfer of property in works contracts. Outcome: in favour of revenue. Pre-GST but relevant to works-contract material sourcing. Not legal advice. Contractors sourcing aggregates from unregistered quarries in Tamil Nadu remain exposed to purchase tax despite works-contract characterisation debates.
Shyam Traders v. State of West Bengal
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Shyam Traders, Calcutta High Court (WPA 2357 of 2025, 9 July 2026), contested an appellate order under Section 107 that, while dealing with an ex parte adjudication confirming tax, interest and penalty for alleged short payment of outward supplies and excess input tax credit, directed the parties to appear before the Adjudicating Authority for further proceedings instead of deciding within appellate powers. The court held that Section 107 and allied provisions (including Section 161 on appellate procedure) permit the Appellate Authority only to confirm, modify or annul the order under appeal—not to remand for a fresh adjudicatory round as if exercising original jurisdiction. The remand exceeded statutory appellate competence. The impugned appellate order was set aside with direction that the Appellate Authority decide the appeal on merits within the confines of Section 107. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded for proper appellate adjudication.
Sepl Infra (P.) Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals)
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Sepl Infra (P.) Ltd. challenged before the Karnataka High Court (WP 104931 of 2026, 9 July 2026) the dismissal of its appeal under Section 107 after it belatedly discovered an adjudication order that had not been uploaded in the regular GST portal tab and was not fully served. The assessee had meanwhile complied with the statutory pre-deposit under Sections 78 and 79. The court found that delayed knowledge coupled with deficient portal communication and incomplete service justified writ relief despite limitation arguments. The appellate dismissal was set aside, delay in filing the appeal was condoned, and the appeal was restored for adjudication on merits. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) for a merit-based decision in accordance with Section 107.
Rajat Dalmia v. Assistant Commissioner of Revenue
In favour of the assessee
Rajat Dalmia (W.P.A. No. 1031 of 2026) succeeded before the High Court of Calcutta on 9 July 2026 against West Bengal GST proceedings. Form GST DRC-01 omitted date, time, and venue for personal hearing and marked those fields as not applicable, effectively denying hearing under Sections 73 and 75 read with Rule 142. Assessment and demands founded on the defective notice were vitiated and set aside with liberty for fresh proceedings after proper hearing opportunity. Outcome favoured the assessee. Portal-generated DRC-01 templates must not leave hearing slots blank where adverse action is proposed. Procedural rigour protects assessees at the show-cause stage. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-09, High Court of Calcutta recorded in favour of the assessee in W.P.A. NO. 1031 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73, CGST S.75, CGST Rules R.142. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Marginmart Ifosystems (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioncr CGST
In favour of the revenue
Marginmart Ifosystems (P) Ltd. filed an Article 226 writ before the High Court of Delhi (decided 9 July 2026) against penalty proceedings for issuing tax invoices without actual supply and wrongful availment of input tax credit, after investigation found the purported recipient entity non-existent. The company raised jurisdiction and procedural grounds at the threshold. The court noted an effective statutory remedy under Section 107 to challenge the penalty order on merits and on jurisdictional questions, with Section 126 governing mitigating circumstances at adjudication. Writ jurisdiction was not exercised at this stage; the petitioner was directed to pursue appeal, leaving all issues open for the Appellate Authority. The outcome favoured the revenue on maintainability rather than on substantive penalty merits. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
JK Technology v. Deputy State Tax Officer
In favour of the assessee
The Telangana High Court (9 July 2026, Writ Petition No. 21690 of 2026) quashed cancellation of JK Technology’s GST registration where the show-cause notice spoke of fraud but the cancellation order rested on non-furnishing of returns—a ground not specified in the SCN. The writ challenged both the SCN and the cancellation order as procedurally defective. Under Section 29 and Rule 22 of the CGST Rules, grounds must be precise, supported by material, and consistently pursued through notice, reply and final order; the assessee must know the exact case it must meet. Breach of that requirement vitiated the entire cancellation chain because the authority could not rely on a new rationale at the order stage. Registration was restored forthwith; the department retained liberty to issue a fresh SCN on proper grounds with supporting documents and to follow Rule 22 procedure. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. The ruling is a reminder that registration proceedings cannot shift rationales between notice and order. Editorial summary for Chartered Accountants; not legal advice.
Sanat Kumar Hazra v. Assistant Commissioner, State Tax, Howrah and Kadamtala Charge
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Sanat Kumar Hazra (WPA No. 27554 of 2025) challenged an ex parte Section 74 order uploaded on the wrong GST portal tab, escaping notice. The High Court of Calcutta on 8 July 2026 set aside the order and granted opportunity to contest the show cause notice subject to deposit of Rs. 1 lakh towards disputed tax under Sections 74 and 75. Outcome: assessee favoured with conditional remand. Portal hygiene and assessee vigilance on all tabs matter for timely challenge. Deposit conditions balance revenue protection with restored hearing rights. CAs should monitor DRC-07 publications across portal sections. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-08, High Court of Calcutta recorded in favour of the assessee; matter remanded in WPA NO. 27554 OF 2025. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74, CGST S.75. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.