Every ruling, in plain sight
Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.
278 rulings
DG Anti Profiteering, Director General of Anti-Profiteering, DGAP v. Townpark Buildcon (P.) Ltd
In favour of the revenue
The GST Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi (NAPA No. 80 (PB) of 2025, 2 July 2026), heard the Director General of Anti-Profiteering against Townpark Buildcon Pvt. Ltd., a real estate developer. Section 171 CGST and Rules 126 and 133 require passing on commensurate benefit of rate or ITC reduction to recipients. The developer did not dispute that additional ITC benefit after GST rate changes was not fully passed to 149 homebuyers who booked before issuance of the occupancy certificate. The DGAP’s project-level computation of the profiteered amount up to the certificate date was upheld. The Tribunal directed refund of the remaining profiteered sum, including GST, to affected buyers under the anti-profiteering framework. Outcome favoured revenue. Developers should align pre-OC pricing with accepted DGAP methodology at project level.
Alder Crafts v. State of Himachal Pradesh
In favour of the assessee
Alder Crafts challenged GST proceedings before the Himachal Pradesh High Court (CWP 15378/2025, 2 July 2026) after a show cause notice appeared only under the GST portal tab "Additional Notices" rather than "Notices and Orders." Ex parte adjudication and recovery followed. The petitioner relied on Sections 169, 75 and 79 CGST. The Division Bench held there was no valid service on the tab where assessees ordinarily expect primary communications, rendering the subsequent ex parte order and recovery notice unsustainable. All impugned proceedings were quashed with liberty to the revenue to issue a fresh notice through valid modes and tabs. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. The judgment adds to High Court jurisprudence distinguishing main portal notices from ancillary tabs, emphasizing that mis-tabbed uploads frustrate natural justice and cannot trigger coercive recovery or final liability.
Santu Das v. Assistant Commissioner of CGST & C. EX, Chandannagore Division
In favour of the assessee
Santu Das filed proceedings before the Calcutta High Court (decision 1 July 2026) against the Assistant Commissioner, CGST & Central Excise, Chandannagore Division. Input tax credit for 2018–19 was denied on the sole ground that returns were filed after the original deadline in Section 16(4). Parliament later amended the CGST Act to insert Section 16(5), retrospectively relaxing the time limit so that ITC could be taken where returns were filed by 30 November 2021. The petitioner’s returns met that extended cut-off. The court held the department could not ignore the amendment and reject credit purely for delay. The impugned order was set aside; outcome in favour of the assessee. Sections 16, 73 and Rule 142 were engaged. This summary is for professional reference only and is not legal advice.
Clear Secured Service (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner (ST)
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Clear Secured Service (P.) Ltd. (Madras High Court, WP 23402 of 2026, 1 July 2026, Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy, J.) had input tax credit reversed following Section 73 show cause tied to supplier whose registration was later cancelled. Assessee produced bank statements, tax invoices, e-way bills, ledgers and GSTR-2A/2B reconciliations under Section 16 eligibility principles. Adjudicating authority reversed ITC solely due to supplier cancellation without evaluating documentary proof or granting opportunity to adduce further evidence (Sections 74 and 75 procedural fairness). Order unsustainable; set aside with direction for fresh adjudication considering entire record. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Recipient ITC defences require merit review beyond supplier status changes. Not legal advice. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.
State Tax Officer v. Besto Tradelink Ltd
See the decision
The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi (Company Appeal (AT) (Ins.) No. 1451 of 2024, 30 June 2026), rejected the State Tax Department’s attempt to rank as a secured creditor for GST dues in CIRP against Besto Tradelink Ltd. Section 82 CGST creates a statutory charge but does not override the insolvency priority under the IBC. The department had not objected during the resolution process, and the approved resolution plan had been fully implemented. Challenging unsecured treatment thereafter lacked merit. Outcome turned on insolvency law interaction with GST recovery. Tax authorities in CIRP should assert claims timely; statutory charge alone does not equate to secured status in liquidation or resolution. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
Singapore Airlines Ltd. v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Singapore Airlines Ltd. approached the High Court of Bombay in Writ Petition No. 2702 of 2026, decided on 29 June 2026, to challenge IGST demands framed on Computer Reservation System (CRS) services. The revenue treated the airline as the recipient liable under the CGST Act, including proceedings under section 74. The airline contended it neither received the services in question nor paid consideration, so the prior issue was whether it was a "recipient" at all—a question going to jurisdiction rather than mere tax quantification. The Court held the writ petition maintainable despite availability of a statutory appeal, because the dispute touched the competence of the adjudicating authority and warranted deeper examination of sections 5 and 6 read with section 74. The outcome at this stage favoured the assessee on maintainability, leaving substantive liability to be determined in appropriate proceedings. This editorial summary is for professional awareness among chartered accountants and is not legal advice.
Fives Call - KCP Ltd. v. Chief Commissioner of Customs
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Fives Call-KCP Ltd. filed before the Madras High Court (WP 30288/2023, 29 June 2026) against rejection of IGST refund on zero-rated exports. The department relied on Board Circular No. 37/2018, which the court noted was struck down as inconsistent with IGST Sections 16 and 20 and CGST Rule 96. Rejection without examining the claim under governing statute and rules was unsustainable. The matter was remanded for re-adjudication on merits under proper legal standards, including verification of shipping bills and refund application. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. Exporters should cite this when refunds are denied solely on circular grounds after judicial invalidation of restrictive CBIC guidance, ensuring adjudicators apply Section 16 and Rule 96 rather than obsolete circular tests.
State of Karnataka v. Yogisha R
In favour of the revenue
In Writ Appeal No. 1951 of 2025, the Karnataka High Court decided on 25 June 2026 whether writ courts may direct GST authorities to reimburse tax on state works contracts. Contractor Yogisha R had sought directions against the department of finance and tax officers. The Court reaffirmed that GST officers cannot be compelled to reimburse incremental tax; any pass-through claim arises only under the works contract with the government employer. Section 9 of the CGST Act governs levy, assessment, and recovery independently of tender language. Proper writ relief is to direct the employer department to consider representations for contractual reimbursement, not to bind GST administration. Appeal favoured the revenue on separation of remedies. This summary is not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment and current notifications before advising clients on compliance steps.
SKM Infraventure (P.) Ltd. v. CT & GST Office
In favour of the revenue
SKM Infraventure (P.) Ltd. challenged Section 74 CGST proceedings before the Orissa High Court (WP(C) 7800/2026, 25 June 2026), alleging non-service of notices uploaded on the GST portal and denial of fair adjudication on fraud allegations. The department defended service through the common portal under Section 169 and produced portal history. The court examined records showing assessee participation in the proceedings and found claims of ignorance lacked credibility. Portal service was upheld as valid in these facts. The writ petition was dismissed. Outcome: in favour of the revenue. Unlike Luxmi Traders fact patterns, Orissa distinguishes cases where portal records demonstrate actual engagement, allowing Section 74 adjudication to stand when service is effectively acknowledged by conduct rather than bare denial in writ proceedings.
Rashmi Agency v. Deputy Commissioner CT & GST
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Rashmi Agency petitioned the High Court of Orissa (W.P.(C) No. 17470 of 2026, decided 25 June 2026) for refund of GST amount paid under protest after securing appellate relief in related proceedings. The Deputy Commissioner denied refund citing potential department appeal or unexpired limitation despite no pending proceeding or Commissioner withholding order in RFD-07 Part A at the relevant date. Under Sections 54 and 112 read with Rule 92, the court held this reasoning unlawful as a basis to withhold amounts already adjudicated in the assessee's favour. The denial was set aside and the matter remanded for refund processing. Outcome favoured the assessee. Refund follow-up after appellate success cannot rest on speculative future appeals alone. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
Prafulla Kumar Mohanty v. Additional Commissioner, CT & GST (Appeal)
In favour of the revenue
Prafulla Kumar Mohanty (Orissa High Court, W.P.(C) 11764 of 2026, 25 June 2026) initially sought writ relief when an adjudication order under Section 74 of the CGST Act was affirmed by the Additional Commissioner (Appeals), arguing that no functional GST Appellate Tribunal existed. Subsequent central notification constituted the GSTAT and extended appeal timelines under Section 112 read with Section 109, activating the full appellate ladder including tribunal deposit norms. The court held that once an efficacious statutory remedy exists, Article 226 writs should not short-circuit the hierarchy except in rare cases of demonstrated futility or jurisdictional nullity—neither shown here. Petitioner was directed to file appeal before GSTAT within notified periods and comply with pre-deposit requirements under Section 112 rather than continue writ proceedings. Outcome: in favour of the revenue. Chartered accountants advising clients post-GSTAT constitution should map Section 107 first appeal and Section 112 tribunal routes. Not legal advice.
Ayiswarya Polymers v. Assistant commissioner of GST and Central Excise
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Ayiswarya Polymers filed WP No. 22814 of 2026 before the Madras High Court; order 25 June 2026 on Section 128A waiver. The assessee discharged the entire tax demand within the scheme timeline but mistakenly remitted a portion under the IGST head although no IGST liability existed on the notice. The department rejected waiver of interest and penalty solely for wrong head allocation despite full monetary compliance. The court held that substantial compliance with the demand should not be defeated by a clerical misclassification of payment head, and remanded the matter with opportunity to rectify head-wise payment. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. Sections 128A, 73 and 77 were cited. CAs should verify payment heads under amnesty. Not legal advice.
A2Z Infra Engineering Ltd. v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
A2Z Infra Engineering Ltd. challenged overlapping demands for the same tax period before the Calcutta High Court in WPA No. 22309 of 2024, decided 25 June 2026. The assessee had filed GSTR-3B by 30 November 2021. Retrospective insertion of section 16(5) through Finance legislation extended and regularized input tax credit availment timelines for specified cases from 1 July 2017. The Court held a subsequent section 73 demand was unsustainable given that benefit and quashed the later order, remanding the original order-in-original for re-adjudication with verified return dates under sections 16 and 73. Outcome favoured the assessee with remand. Chartered accountants should map client facts to post-2024 section 16 amendments. Not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment and current notifications before advising clients on compliance steps.
Sunders Kitchen (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Sunders Kitchen (P.) Ltd. approached the Bombay High Court (24 June 2026, Writ Petition No. 503 of 2026) after cancellation of GST registration for non-filing of GSTR-3B, in circumstances where the department did not allege fraud, fake billing or intentional tax evasion. The company undertook to pay all outstanding GST with applicable interest, late fee and penalty and to remain compliant prospectively. Under Sections 29 and 30 read with Rules 22 and 23, the Court directed restoration of registration upon fulfilment of that payment undertaking, with the explicit condition that failure to pay would result in dismissal of the petition. Outcome: in favour of the assessee on payment condition. Useful for food and hospitality companies seeking restoration after pure compliance default. Not legal advice.
S R Enterprise v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
S R Enterprise, a partnership firm, obtained relief from the Gauhati High Court (24 June 2026, WP(C) No. 3345 of 2026) where cancellation rested on a stale show-cause notice issued years earlier, followed by nearly two years of departmental inaction and an eventual cancellation order passed without affording a proper or timely personal hearing. The firm contended that dormant proceedings could not be revived to cancel registration without fresh notice and opportunity. Under Section 29 and Section 169, registration orders must conform to statutory requirements, reasoned process and basic fairness. Cancellation was set aside; the authority may initiate fresh proceedings if grounds still exist, but without excusing the firm’s ongoing obligation to file returns and pay tax. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Addresses delay and dormant SCNs in registration cancellation. Not legal advice.
VRAA and Co. v. Assistant Commissioner of GST and Central Excise
In favour of the revenue
VRAA and Co., a partnership firm, challenged garnishee action before the High Court of Madras (WP No. 22458 of 2026, decided 23 June 2026). Firm tax dues had crystallised without successful challenge; a partner's personal bank account was attached through Form GST DRC-13 under Section 79(1)(c)(i). The firm argued that Section 83 provisional attachment limits applied. The court held partners remain jointly and severally liable for firm dues and garnishee recovery under Section 79 against a partner's account was permissible once liability was final. Section 83 governed provisional attachment in pending proceedings, not this recovery mode. No ground for writ interference arose. The petition was dismissed in favour of the Assistant Commissioner. This editorial summary is not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment for exact findings.
Samadhan Seva Samiti v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Samadhan Seva Samiti succeeded before the Patna High Court (23 June 2026, Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 945 of 2026) where registration was cancelled on the basis of a notice merely uploaded on the GST common portal without service through other prescribed modes, and the cancellation order itself reflected procedural defects. The State fairly admitted that proper service had not been effected on the society. Under Section 29 and Section 169, valid service of show-cause notice and a real hearing are mandatory before registration is cancelled; a unilateral portal upload without proof of receipt cannot substitute for service. Procedural breach vitiated the cancellation. The order was set aside with liberty to the department to proceed afresh after due compliance with service requirements and opportunity of hearing. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Important for societies on portal-only notices. Not legal advice.
S. Thiruvenkadam v. Commissioner of Municipal Administration
In favour of the revenue
S. Thiruvenkadam, who acquired rights to collect market fees through public auction, challenged GST on that activity before the Madras High Court in W.P. No. 29338 of 2024, decided 23 June 2026. He was not a "local authority" under Article 243W of the Constitution; commercial exploitation of auctioned collection rights was held not exempt under section 11 of the CGST Act. Tender conditions required payment of applicable taxes, and concessions or waivers during the COVID period did not create a right to withhold statutory GST while dues remained unpaid. The writ was dismissed, favouring the revenue. The judgment clarifies limits of municipal-function exemptions when fee collection is privatised. This summary is for CA clients in local fee contracts and is not legal advice.
Renaatus Projects (P.) Ltd. v. Joint Director, Directorate General of gst Intelligence, Chennai
In favour of the revenue
Renaatus Projects (P.) Ltd. filed W.A. No. 190 of 2026 before the Madras High Court; decision 23 June 2026. A GST-registered contractor in Tamil Nadu executed construction of a Supreme Court building at Port Louis, Mauritius, funded under a Government of India grant. DGGI issued a show-cause notice alleging taxable supply linked to India through procurement and financial consolidation. The company sought writ quashing as without jurisdiction. The division bench held the challenge premature: whether IGST Sections 7 and 12 treat the arrangement as supply in India requires factual examination, not a patent jurisdictional defect. Writ appeal dismissed; outcome for revenue. CGST definitions in Section 2 and Section 7 were also referenced. Not legal advice. Offshore construction under foreign grants may still face IGST scrutiny if Indian nexus is pleaded; respondents may contest facts at adjudication.
Vishal @ Vishal Dadaso Tamkhade v. Director General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence
In favour of the assessee
Vishal @ Vishal Dadaso Tamkhade and others filed Criminal Petition Nos. 8230–8234 and 8236 of 2026 before the Karnataka High Court; order 22 June 2026. DGGI investigated large-scale GST evasion under Sections 132 and 69. Petitioners sought anticipatory bail to approach a court in another state. The court granted limited interim protection for ten days on personal bond, sureties, passport surrender and cooperation with investigation, finding no immediate flight risk. Outcome: partial relief for assessees. Shows conditional interim shield during multi-state investigations. This editorial summary is not legal advice. Ten-day protection allows forum shopping for bail while preserving investigative oversight through passport and bond conditions. Full anticipatory bail was not granted; petitioners must return if protection expires without regular bail.