Every ruling, in plain sight

Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.

278 rulings

High Court of Punjab & HaryanaSupply Valuation

Cvent India (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of CGST

See the decision

Cvent India (P.) Ltd., an IT and IT-enabled services provider, filed before the Punjab and Haryana High Court (CWP 22461/2023, 21 July 2026) against rejection of refund of unutilized input tax credit for an intervening period while refunds for earlier and later periods were allowed when it was treated as an exporter. IGST Sections 2, 13 and 16 and CGST Section 54 framed place-of-supply and refund issues. The department reclassified the petitioner as intermediary for the disputed period without material distinction in services rendered. The court found that action illegal and arbitrary, set aside the appellate order and restored equitable refund treatment. Outcome favoured the assessee on merits of classification consistency. Export-oriented IT companies should ensure uniform characterization across periods to avoid selective intermediary denial of Section 54 refunds.

IGST S.2IGST S.13IGST S.16CGST S.54
High Court of CalcuttaDemands Adjudication

B. Enterprise v. State of West Bengal

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

B. Enterprise (Calcutta High Court, WPA 1078 of 2026, 21 July 2026, Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.) faced show cause proposing input tax credit reversal for portal-flagged mismatches during relevant period. Notice lacked hearing details and appeared under ‘Additional notices and orders’ tab rather than primary notice channel, leading to ex parte order under Sections 73 and 75. Court held deficient notice and absent hearing breached natural justice, vitiating ex parte confirmation. Impugned order set aside; adjudicating authority to re-adjudicate after proper notice specifying hearing date, time and venue. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Emphasizes monitoring all portal tabs and insisting on Section 75(4) compliance. Informational summary. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.73CGST S.75CGST S.169
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

Modern Engineers and Contractors v. Deputy Assistant Commissioner ST

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Modern Engineers and Contractors (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 19677 of 2026, 20 July 2026) challenged summary assessment simultaneously deficient in assessing officer signature and Document Identification Number. Court held twin defects fatal under Sections 160 and 169—neither curative section nor deemed service via portal uploads converts defective draft into binding order. Invalidity was inherent, warranting quashing without merits inquiry into underlying tax computation. Assessee entitled to fresh assessment after compliant notice, DIN generation, signature, and opportunity of hearing before Deputy Assistant Commissioner (ST). Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. Demonstrates cumulative procedural failures may short-circuit demand even where substantive liability debated. Informational for CAs. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.160CGST S.169
High Court of PatnaService Of Notices Orders

Umagaurav (P.) Ltd. v. State of Bihar

In favour of the revenue

Umagaurav (P.) Ltd. challenged ex parte GST demand before the Patna High Court (CWJC 4914/2026, 17 July 2026), alleging non-service and denial of hearing. The department showed show cause notices and reminders through portal and registered email with specific input tax credit mismatch figures under Sections 73, 75, 79 and 107 CGST and Rule 142. The petitioner neither categorically denied email receipt nor disclosed correct GSTR-2A ITC to rebut the mismatch. Article 226 scope was noted: writ courts do not rehear merits when procedural objections are implausible. Bare allegations lacked credibility against departmental records evidencing participation. The writ failed. Outcome: in favour of the revenue. Bihar assessees cannot rely on generic non-service pleas where email and portal trails plus undisputed ITC discrepancies show effective engagement, contrasting Subhash Kumar Sah where no such record existed.

CGST S.169CGST S.73CGST S.75CGST Rules R.142+3 more
High Court of UttarakhandAppellate Authority

Radhika Furniture @ Radha Devi v. Commissioner, State Goods and Services Tax

In favour of the revenue

Radhika Furniture @ Radha Devi and another assessee sought condonation of delay beyond GST appeal periods before the Uttarakhand High Court (Writ Petition Nos. 716 of 2024 and 86 of 2025, 17 July 2026), invoking Section 5 of the Limitation Act read with Section 29(2). The Court held CGST is a special fiscal statute with its own limitation and restricted condonation under Section 107, excluding Section 5 by necessary implication. Appeals beyond the prescribed period could not be entertained. Outcome favoured revenue. GST practitioners cannot rely on general Limitation Act Section 5 for late Section 107 appeals in this jurisdiction. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107Limitation Act S.5Limitation Act S.29
High Court of GauhatiDemands Adjudication

North East Petrochemicals v. Union of India

In favour of the revenue

North East Petrochemicals challenged consolidated show cause notice and a single order covering multiple financial years before the High Court of Gauhati (WP(C) No. 2884 of 2026, 17 July 2026). Under Sections 73 and 107, Justice Devashis Barua held issuance of consolidated notice and order was within the proper officer’s jurisdiction and authority; competence could not be assailed on that ground alone. Merits were left open for statutory appeal. Outcome favoured the revenue on the jurisdictional point. This Gauhati view differs from several sister High Courts that quash composite orders in Section 73 matters. Practitioners must weigh forum-specific precedent when advising on multi-year notices. Informational summary only; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-17, High Court of Gauhati recorded in favour of the revenue in WP(C) NO. 2884 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73, CGST S.107. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.73CGST S.107
High Court of PatnaRegistration

Munna Chaudhary v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Munna Chaudhary, a works contractor, succeeded in the Patna High Court (17 July 2026, Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 4593 of 2026) against cancellation of GST registration for non-filing of returns without affording personal hearing, and against subsequent rejection of revocation where the SCN lacked officer identity and mandatory Document Identification Number. The petitioner argued that cancellation and rejection orders were passed in violation of audi alteram partem and centralised communication norms. Under Section 29, Rule 22, Section 30, Section 160 and Rule 23, hearing and proper notice forms are mandatory before registration is cancelled or restoration is denied; appellate orders that overlooked these defects suffered jurisdictional error. Impugned orders were set aside and registration directed restored subject to lawful compliance by the assessee. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Highlights compliance with natural justice and DIN requirements in registration proceedings. Not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST S.75CGST Rules R.22CGST S.30+2 more
High Court of KarnatakaRecovery Attachment

BKR Services (P.) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

BKR Services (P) Ltd. challenged garnishee recovery before the High Court of Karnataka (Writ Petition No. 21878 of 2026, decided 17 July 2026). Form GST DRC-13 garnishee notices under Section 79 read with Rule 145 targeted the private limited company for GST dues of a deceased person's proprietary concern, treating them as one liability pool. Adjudication had also failed to consider post-death liability under Sections 73 and 93. The court quashed DRC-13 notices, related recovery orders, and DRC-07 demand summaries, restoring proceedings for fresh decision on whether the company or its assets were legally liable for the deceased's dues. Outcome favoured the assessee with remand. Corporate personality and estate liability must be adjudicated separately. This editorial summary is not legal advice.

CGST S.79CGST Rules R.145CGST S.93CGST S.73
High Court of PatnaService Of Notices Orders

Subhash Kumar Sah v. Commissioner, CGST and CX

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Subhash Kumar Sah filed before the Patna High Court (CWJC 3599/2026, 16 July 2026) against cancellation of GST registration based solely on uploading a show cause notice on the portal, without email, registered post or personal hearing. The assessee contended non-compliance with Section 29 read with Rule 22 for suspension and cancellation. Sections 169 and 29 CGST and Rule 22 were invoked. The Division Bench held portal upload alone insufficient for valid service; personal service by prescribed modes and hearing were required before cancellation. The cancellation order was set aside with direction to re-issue show cause notice, afford hearing and pass a reasoned decision. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. Registration cancellation cases in Bihar must comply with multi-mode service expectations beyond silent portal posting.

CGST S.169CGST S.29CGST Rules R.22
High Court of ChhattisgarhDemands Adjudication

Shri Shyam Trading Company v. Commissioner of Chhattisgarh State Tax

In favour of the assessee

Shri Shyam Trading Company (WPT No. 140 of 2021) challenged a Section 73 assessment based only on a summary show cause notice without a separate notice specifying reasons as Rule 142 requires. The High Court of Chhattisgarh on 16 July 2026 held non-compliance with Section 73 and Rule 142 vitiated proceedings, quashing the assessment and summary notice with liberty for fresh lawful notice. Outcome favoured the assessee. Chhattisgarh aligns with broader jurisprudence distinguishing DRC-01 summaries from substantive Section 73(1) notices. Trading assessees receiving bare summaries should raise statutory objections early. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-16, High Court of Chhattisgarh recorded in favour of the assessee in WPT NO. 140 OF 2021. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73, CGST Rules R.142. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.73CGST Rules R.142
High Court of TelanganaArrest Bail

Sandeep Kumar Goel v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Sandeep Kumar Goel, designated partner of an LLP (Telangana High Court, Criminal Petition 9264 of 2026, 16 July 2026, N. Tukaramji, J.), sought anticipatory bail when DG GST authorities alleged fraudulent ITC availed through fake suppliers and sought arrest for custodial interrogation under Sections 69 and 132 CGST (BNSS Section 482). Department already possessed books, returns and electronic records; petitioner cooperated with summons and showed no credible flight risk. Court found no justification for preventive custody solely to repeat questioning available through bail supervision. Anticipatory bail granted with stringent conditions including appearance and non-tampering undertakings. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Useful for LLPs where partners face parallel liability allegations but investigation materials are largely in department custody. Not legal advice.

CGST S.69CGST S.132BNSS S.482
High Court of CalcuttaPenalty

Raju Sharma v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Bureau of Investigation

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Raju Sharma, operating as a sole proprietorship, challenged penalty before the High Court of Calcutta (WPA No. 16100 of 2026, decided 16 July 2026) for alleged issuance of invoices without supply and availment of input tax credit without receipt of goods. Adjudication under Section 122 relied heavily on statements of third parties; the assessee's request for cross-examination of those deponents was denied. Under Sections 122, 75, and 136, the court held that denial of cross-examination on material used to impose penalty amounted to gross violation of principles of natural justice. The penalty order was set aside and the matter remanded for fresh adjudication with a meaningful opportunity for cross-examination. The outcome favoured the assessee with remand rather than final acquittal on merits.

CGST S.122CGST S.75CGST S.136
High Court of CalcuttaService Of Notices Orders

Raju Ghosh v. State of West Bengal

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Raju Ghosh challenged West Bengal GST proceedings before the Calcutta High Court (WPA 13917/2026, 16 July 2026) where adjudication orders and related notices were uploaded only under the portal tab "Additional Notices and Orders," leaving him unaware and without effective hearing. Recovery from the electronic credit ledger followed despite no reply to the underlying show cause notice. Sections 169, 73 and 107 framed service and appellate context. Justice Smita Das De held the sequence violated natural justice. All impugned orders and recovery notices were quashed and the matter remitted for fresh hearing after proper service. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. Combined with sibling Calcutta judgments, it establishes a strong local practice against ancillary-tab service and credit-ledger recovery without prior valid notice and personal hearing under Section 75.

CGST S.169CGST S.73CGST S.107
High Court of CalcuttaAppellate Authority

Raju Ghosh v. State of WB

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

The Calcutta High Court (WPA 6129 of 2026, 16 July 2026) intervened where Raju Ghosh received a Form GST DRC-01 show cause notice for tax periods March 2021 to April 2022 only under the portal tab “Additional notice and orders,” leaving him unable to respond. He learned of the adjudication order dated 3 July 2025 after a recovery email in November 2025, by which time substantial amounts had already been debited from his electronic credit ledger. His appeal under Section 107 of the CGST/WBGST Acts was dismissed on 28 January 2026 solely for limitation, without merits. The court held that electronic placement in a non-standard tab amounted to defective service and denial of natural justice under the service framework (including Section 169). The explained delay warranted condonation. The appellate order was quashed with direction to decide the appeal on merits by 30 September 2026; pre-deposit already made sufficed and recovery was not to be influenced by the order. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded.

CGST S.107CGST S.169
High Court of PatnaAppellate Authority

Rajnish Kumar v. Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise

In favour of the assessee

Rajnish Kumar filed a writ before the Patna High Court (Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.1338 of 2026, 16 July 2026) against adjudication and recovery orders under Sections 78 and 107 CGST. Prasad and Mishra JJ permitted withdrawal with liberty to file a statutory appeal before the Appellate Authority, excluding writ period from limitation and allowing condonation, while barring re-agitation of one previously adjudicated contention; other grounds remained open. Outcome favoured the assessee on remedial routing. Partial issue preclusion may apply when writ converts to appeal after earlier partial adjudication. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107CGST S.78
High Court of ChhattisgarhDemands Adjudication

N.N. Wires and Steels (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

N.N. Wires and Steels (P.) Ltd. (WPT No. 109 of 2021) succeeded on remand directions before the High Court of Chhattisgarh on 16 July 2026. A Section 74 show cause notice did not disclose specific reasons and relied-on documents were not supplied, denying meaningful opportunity under Sections 74, 79, and 83. Recovery and bank attachment founded on the defective notice were unsustainable. The court quashed consequential coercive steps and required fresh notice with specific reasons and document supply. Outcome: assessee favoured with remand. Reinforces document transparency and reasoned SCNs in fraud-track proceedings. Chartered accountants advising on DGGI or state fraud notices should verify annexures and reasons at inception. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-16, High Court of Chhattisgarh recorded in favour of the assessee; matter remanded in WPT NO. 109 OF 2021. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74, CGST S.79, CGST S.83. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.74CGST S.79CGST S.83
High Court of KeralaDemands Adjudication

Flower City Restaurant v. State Tax Officer

In favour of the assessee

Flower City Restaurant approached the High Court of Kerala (WP(C) No. 24188 of 2026) against a consolidated show-cause notice and a composite order-in-original for multiple financial years relating to tax or input tax credit, without allegation of fraud. Decided on 16 July 2026 under Section 73 of the CGST Act, the court held such clubbed proceedings invalid. Both the consolidated notice and the composite order were quashed, with liberty to the State Tax Officer to initiate fresh, year-specific proceedings. The judgment aligns with the growing High Court consensus that composite assessment in standard Section 73 matters cannot substitute separate adjudication for each period. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Informational summary only; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-16, High Court of Kerala recorded in favour of the assessee in WP(C) NO. 24188 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.73
High Court of GauhatiInput Tax Credit

Advance Engineering Farms and Equipments v. State of Assam

In favour of the assessee

Advance Engineering Farms and Equipments challenged input tax credit denial before the Gauhati High Court, decided 16 July 2026. The assessee paid GST to registered sellers and held valid tax invoices, yet credit was denied because sellers failed to file returns or deposit tax. Justice Devashis Baruah held denial unlawful under section 16 read with section 39 and Rules 36 and 37A. Remedy for supplier default targets the supplier, not a bona fide purchaser without collusion. Rectification demand treating availed credit as excess was set aside. Decision aligns with purchaser-protection trends in supplier-default litigation. Outcome favoured the assessee. This editorial summary is intended for CAs and is not legal advice. Readers should consult the full judgment and current notifications before advising clients on compliance steps.

CGST S.16CGST S.39CGST Rules R.36CGST Rules R.37A
High Court of DelhiAppellate Authority

Sodexo India Services (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India

In favour of the revenue

Sodexo India Services (P.) Ltd. filed a writ before the Delhi High Court (W.P.(C) 9153 of 2026, decided 15 July 2026) assailing an order-in-original passed under Sections 74 and 75 of the CGST Act after a detailed departmental audit. The assessee had participated throughout, filed comprehensive replies, and supplied documents, yet complained that the adjudicating authority neither meaningfully considered its submissions nor called for additional records before confirming demand. The revenue contended that adequate opportunity was afforded and that grievances went to appreciation of evidence, not procedural fairness. Invoking Article 226, the Division Bench (Anil Kshetrapal and Shail Jain, JJ.) reaffirmed that where statutory appeal under Section 107 exists, writ courts normally refrain from adjudicating merits unless exceptional circumstances—such as clear jurisdictional void or gross violation of natural justice—are shown. Mere disagreement with outcome or depth of reasoning does not qualify. The writ was dismissed, leaving the assessee to pursue appeal with pre-deposit. Outcome: in favour of the revenue. This summary is informational for chartered accountants and not legal advice.

CGST S.107CGST S.74CGST S.75Constitution Art.226
High Court of OrissaAppellate Authority

Magnum Estates (P.) Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner, GST (Appeals)

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Magnum Estates Pvt. Ltd. filed before the Orissa High Court (W.P. (C) No. 34660 of 2025, 15 July 2026) when pre-deposit for appeal was stymied because DRC-07 misclassified interest as tax and rectification under Sections 161 and 50 was time-barred. Issues spanned ITC reversal, interest and penalty under Sections 73, 107 and 112 CGST. The Court remanded to the Appellate Authority for fresh hearing rather than forcing immediate GSTAT appeal, finding relegation unjust in the circumstances. Outcome favoured the assessee with remand. Correct DRC-07 break-up is critical for pre-deposit compliance. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107CGST S.50CGST S.73CGST S.112+1 more