Every ruling, in plain sight
Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.
278 rulings
Brahmaputra Tele Productions (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Brahmaputra Tele Productions (P.) Ltd. (Gauhati High Court, 29 July 2026, Devashis Baruah, J.) impugned Assam GST order dated 30 April 2024 imposing tax, interest and penalty for FY 2018-19 under Sections 73 and 75. Petitioner demonstrated no State notification extended limitation under Section 168A for that financial year, unlike centrally notified extensions. Statutory period for passing order expired 31 December 2023; April 2024 order time-barred and void. Court set aside demand. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Practitioners must verify State-specific Section 168A notifications when defending aged SCNs, not only central COVID-era extensions, before conceding liability. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice. The court left substantive tax merits open for the authority to decide afresh on record.
Ankit Goyal v. Directorate General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence
In favour of the assessee
Ankit Goyal and connected accused (Punjab & Haryana High Court, CRM-M Nos. 12200 and 12204 of 2026, 29 July 2026, Shalini Singh Nagpal, J.) faced prosecution for allegedly creating twenty-six fake firms issuing bogus invoices to circulate fraudulent input tax credit, causing substantial exchequer loss (IGST Section 20, CGST Section 132, BNSS Section 528). After more than seven months in judicial custody, the case rested primarily on documentary and electronic material already seized; threats of evidence destruction or absconding were not substantiated, and petitioners lacked criminal antecedents. The court held further incarceration disproportionate where investigation could proceed on bail with conditions. Regular bail was granted with stringent terms safeguarding investigation integrity. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Illustrates courts weighing duration of custody and evidence nature in large ITC fraud prosecutions. Editorial summary for CAs.
Shanaya Enterprises v. State of Punjab
In favour of the assessee
Shanaya Enterprises filed before the Punjab and Haryana High Court (CWP 23234/2026, 28 July 2026) disputing validity of GST notice and order-in-original served only by portal upload without acknowledgment or reply. The petitioner learned of the demand only when coercive steps were threatened, having never filed a reply. Section 169 CGST applied. The court followed Luxmi Traders v. Union Territory of Chandigarh and held mere upload did not constitute valid service. Impugned proceedings were set aside or restored for response as prayed. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. The judgment is a straightforward application of the Chandigarh High Court standard across Punjab, reinforcing that assessees may contest demands when the department cannot prove effective electronic intimation beyond passive portal posting.
J K Cement Works v. Commissioner CGST
In favour of the assessee
J K Cement Works, a cement manufacturer, petitioned the High Court of Punjab & Haryana (CWP No. 29456 of 2025, decided 28 July 2026) for release of GST refund sanctioned by order in 2022 but withheld by the department pending its belated appeal to the GST Appellate Tribunal, which remained unlisted. Under Sections 54 and 119 of the CGST Act, the court found the petitioner could not be regarded as a fly-by-night operator given its established manufacturing operations. Release of the refund amount was directed subject to the petitioner furnishing an undertaking to redeposit the sum with interest if the departmental appeal ultimately succeeded. The outcome favoured the assessee while protecting revenue interest during appellate uncertainty. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
Incompressible Fluid Control System v. Assistant Commissioner
In favour of the assessee
Incompressible Fluid Control System filed before the Madras High Court; decision 28 July 2026. The assessee sought waiver of interest and penalty under Section 128A where show-cause proceedings under Section 73 arose from belated filing of GSTR-3B and self-assessed tax shortfalls. Revenue argued Section 75(12)’s non obstante clause permitted direct recovery under Section 79, excluding such cases from amnesty. The court held that once liability is determined under Section 73, Section 128A remains available; Section 75(12) does not oust the waiver scheme for those proceedings. Rules 164 and Section 168 supported procedure. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Useful for mapping amnesty eligibility to the section under which demand is raised. Not legal advice. Belated GSTR-3B filers who face Section 73 notices may therefore explore 128A relief if other scheme conditions are satisfied.
Commissioner of Central Tax, CGST, Delhi East v. Samiah International Builder (P.) Ltd
In favour of the assessee
The Commissioner of CGST Delhi East filed CEAC No. 5 of 2024 before the Delhi High Court (28 July 2026) against a CESTAT order on service taxability in favour of Samiah International Builder Pvt. Ltd. Under Central Excise Sections 35G and 35L, appeals on such matters lie to the Supreme Court, not the High Court, absent contrary binding precedent. Kshetarpal and Jain JJ held the appeal not maintainable and relegated the Commissioner to the Supreme Court remedy. Outcome favoured the assessee on maintainability. Departmental appeals from CESTAT must follow the correct forum under Section 35L for the subject matter. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
United Chem India v. Excise and Taxation Officer
In favour of the assessee
United Chem India filed before the Punjab and Haryana High Court (27 July 2026) against notice and order-in-original served only by GST portal upload without acknowledgment or reply. The assessee sought quashing of ex parte liability and restoration of appellate rights dismissed as time-barred. Sections 169 and 146 CGST applied. Following Luxmi Traders, electronic uploading alone was insufficient service; ex parte proceedings were restored to the show cause stage for reply, and appeal limitation did not commence from mere upload. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. The case mirrors parallel Rohit Kapoor bench rulings in July 2026 reinforcing uniform Punjab-Haryana treatment of unacknowledged portal service and aligning with Gugal Electrical and Shanaya Enterprises on limitation for appeals under Section 107.
Nehkhohao Haokip v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
Nehkhohao Haokip and others petitioned the High Court of Gauhati (WP(C) No. 3871 of 2026, 27 July 2026) against repatriation from In-Charge Transfer (ICT) postings in the CBIC. The petitioners had been promoted as Executive Assistants and transferred on ICT after the 2015 Recruitment Rules, which provided separate cadres and no provision for absorption. CBIC policy restricted ICT except in limited cases. The issue was whether orders treating ICT as loan postings and directing repatriation were valid. The court upheld the department's position that ICT postings were impermissible under the rules and policy framework. No infirmity was found in the repatriation orders. The writ was dismissed in favour of the Union of India. This summary is for CA reference on service matters touching GST administration, not legal advice.
Gugal Electrical and Engg. Works v. State of Punjab
In favour of the assessee
Gugal Electrical and Engg. Works filed before the Punjab and Haryana High Court (CWP 21363/2025, 27 July 2026) against show cause notice and order-in-original served solely by GST portal upload without acknowledgment or reply. The assessee had filed appeals rejected as time-barred on the assumption that portal posting started limitation. Sections 169 and 146 CGST were read together; Rule 142 was noted. Following Luxmi Traders, portal-only upload did not constitute valid service or trigger appeal limitation; appeals dismissed as time-barred were restored. Retrospective amendments did not salvage invalid service because Rules did not permit the mode used. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Practitioners facing time-barred appeal dismissals on portal-service assumptions should cite this precedent for restoration of appellate rights when receipt was never established and merits may be heard afresh.
Subhendu Dutta v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Subhendu Dutta obtained conditional relief from the Calcutta High Court (24 July 2026, WPA No. 1144 of 2026) where GST registration was cancelled solely for six consecutive months of non-filing of returns, without allegation of fake invoice or evasion. The petitioner explained delay in approaching the Court due to attempts at departmental resolution. Under Sections 29 and 30, the Court held cancellation could be set aside if the petitioner filed all pending returns and paid tax, interest, fine, penalty and late fees within six weeks from the order, failing which the writ relief would not endure. Outcome: in favour of the assessee on compliance. Illustrates writ courts balancing past default with belated but genuine compliance undertakings rather than leaving taxpayers permanently deregistered. Not legal advice.
Ratul Talukdar v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Ratul Talukdar filed MAT No. 31 of 2026 before the Calcutta High Court, decided 24 July 2026, arising from detention and proposed disposal of perishable goods under section 129 of the CGST Act read with Rule 144A of the CGST Rules. The claimant sought release as owner of the seized consignment but could not establish ownership to the Court's satisfaction under the primary owner-release route. The bench held alternate statutory mechanisms for release remained available and that forcing auction participation without respecting those routes was unsustainable. The appeal was allowed in favour of the assessee on procedural grounds, leaving substantive tax and ownership disputes for appropriate adjudication. The decision assists practitioners advising transporters and claimants in detention scenarios. This summary is not legal advice.
Snowline Travel Ventures LLP v. Commissioner, State Goods and Services Tax
In favour of the assessee
Snowline Travel Ventures LLP obtained quashing from the Uttarakhand High Court (23 July 2026, Writ Petition (M/B) No. 593 of 2026) of a show-cause notice and cancellation order that rested solely on the assessee having filed NIL returns for several consecutive months, without alleging fake registration, non-operation, fraud or any other ground listed under Section 29(2). The firm contended that NIL return filing reflects nil outward supplies and cannot by itself trigger cancellation. The Court agreed that Section 29(2) and Rule 21 do not permit cancellation for NIL returns alone absent an independent statutory breach. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Registration proceedings were invalidated and the department must act only on grounds recognized by law after proper notice. Relevant for travel and service firms filing NIL GSTR-3B. Not legal advice.
SKG Metal Trading v. Commissioner Central Goods and Services Tax
In favour of the revenue
SKG Metal Trading filed a writ before the Delhi High Court in W.P. (C) No. 3895 of 2026, decided 23 July 2026, impugning an ex parte order confirming penalty for wrongful input tax credit. The assessee alleged non-service of the show cause notice and asserted that business had ceased with a registration cancellation application pending. The revenue disputed both service of notice and whether registration still subsisted, creating contested facts. Applying Article 226 principles and provisions including sections 74 and 169 of the CGST Act, the Court held that where such factual disputes exist, extraordinary writ jurisdiction is not the appropriate remedy; the assessee must pursue the statutory appellate channel. For limitation purposes, the period during which the writ remained pending was directed to be excluded from computing time to file appeal. The decision favoured the revenue on maintainability. This summary is not legal advice.
Mohd Hazzak Lohar v. Commissioner State Tax
In favour of the assessee
Mohd Hazzak Lohar approached the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh (WP(C) No. 2434 of 2025, decided 23 July 2026) against a Section 129 penalty on goods in transit. Goods were intercepted and a show cause notice under Section 129(3) was issued, but the final penalty order was passed beyond the mandatory seven-day period measured from detention. Relying on Section 129 read with Section 169, the court reiterated that strict statutory timelines are mandatory and not directory. Delay beyond the permitted window rendered the penalty order invalid in law. The impugned order was quashed and the outcome favoured the assessee, consistent with parallel jurisprudence on Section 129 time limits in the same High Court including Danish Hassan. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
J M D News & Advertisers v. State of Uttarakhand
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
J M D News & Advertisers (Writ Petition (M/B) No. 54 of 2025) obtained quashing and remand from the High Court of Uttarakhand on 23 July 2026. The assessee had filed a manual reply to a show cause notice within time under Sections 73 and 75, but the adjudicating authority passed an order without considering it. The department’s objection to non-electronic filing and the assessee’s absence on a hearing date did not justify ignoring the reply. The court held a gross violation of natural justice vitiated the order. Fresh adjudication must consider the reply on merits. Outcome: assessee favoured with remand. Highlights that substantive compliance with reply timelines matters more than format alone where replies are accepted in practice. Not legal advice.
Ayaz Traders v. Commissioner, State Goods and Service Tax
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Ayaz Traders challenged adjudication before the Uttarakhand High Court (WP 86/2025, 23 July 2026) after its GST registration was cancelled and a show cause notice and order were served only by portal upload under Sections 169 and 73. The assessee contended it was no longer obliged to monitor the portal. The court agreed that exclusive portal service after cancellation is invalid because a non-registrant lacks the statutory duty to track the common portal for new demands. Adjudication and appellate orders were quashed; the revenue may proceed afresh after valid service of the show cause notice. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. This joins Uttarakhand authority requiring alternate modes under Section 169 when registration stands cancelled, protecting taxpayers from silent ex parte liability.
Amar Coop LC Society Ltd. v. State of Haryana
In favour of the assessee
Amar Coop LC Society Ltd. approached the Punjab and Haryana High Court (CWP 15601/2026, 23 July 2026) against ex parte orders and rectification orders served solely by upload on the GST Common Portal. The society cited illiteracy and lack of knowledge of portal monitoring. Sections 169 and 146 CGST and Rule 142 were considered. The court held that mere portal upload is insufficient for valid service affecting limitation where serious civil consequences attach, and that retrospective legal changes did not validate defective service in the facts before it. Portal-only communication did not bind the assessee for limitation or finality purposes. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. The decision aligns with Luxmi Traders principles and cautions revenue against assuming universal digital literacy or continuous portal access, particularly for cooperative and smaller taxpayers.
v. Superintendent Central GST and CX
In favour of the assessee
M/s. J.S. Enterprisers, through legal heir Jyoti Ranjan Mohapatra, challenged section 73 proceedings before the Orissa High Court in W.P.(C) No.13452 of 2026, decided 22 July 2026. Show cause notices and an order-in-original were issued and passed in the name of deceased proprietor Manoranjan Mohapatra despite departmental knowledge of his death and approved non-core amendments to registration showing the legal heir. The Court held adjudication against a dead person is non est and without jurisdiction; section 93 of the CGST Act contemplates liability proceedings against legal representatives, not determination solely in the deceased's name. Participation by a representative did not cure the defect. All impugned SCNs and orders were quashed with liberty to issue fresh notice to the legal heir. Outcome favoured the assessee. Not legal advice.
Shiv Shakti Trading Co. v. State of Haryana
In favour of the assessee
Shiv Shakti Trading Co. and allied petitioners filed consolidated writs before the Punjab & Haryana High Court, decided 22 July 2026. The revenue had initiated proceedings under Sections 73 and 74 of the CGST, PGST and HGST Acts to recover amounts said to represent input tax or credit wrongly availed under the erstwhile Haryana VAT Act before GST. The petitioners contended that pre-GST VAT credits and related disputes fall outside the GST determination and recovery provisions. The court agreed: Sections 73 and 74 address GST-era liabilities, not legacy VAT credits governed by transition rules including Section 140. Proceedings lacked jurisdiction and could not be sustained. Outcome across the batch of petitions: in favour of the assessees. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
B. Enterprise v. State of West Bengal
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
B. Enterprise filed a writ before the Calcutta High Court (WPA 1079/2026, 22 July 2026) impugning ex parte adjudication under Section 73 CGST. Pre-SCN communications, the show cause notice, reminders and the order appeared only under "Additional notices and orders," not the main Notices/Orders tab, and a personal hearing was scheduled before the reply period expired. Section 169 service and Section 75 hearing requirements were invoked. The court found communication legally inadequate and denial of an effective hearing a violation of natural justice. The ex parte order was set aside with direction to pass a fresh order after affording a proper hearing. Outcome: in favour of the assessee; matter remanded. The judgment combines tab-placement defects with premature hearing dates as independent grounds to vitiate GST adjudication.