Every ruling, in plain sight
Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.
278 rulings
Santosh Agrawal (Goyal) v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
Santosh Agrawal (Goyal) filed WPPIL No. 45 of 2026 before the Chhattisgarh High Court; decision 7 August 2026. A private businessman sought public-interest directions for investigation and recovery against named parties for alleged GST evasion under Section 132, relying on documents he supplied. An earlier PIL had been dismissed for want of locus. The court again found no genuine public interest element and dismissed the petition, forfeiting the security deposit. Outcome: in favour of revenue/respondents. Reinforces that tax enforcement PILs require more than private grievance. Summary for professionals; not legal advice. Private parties with tax grievances must use statutory remedies rather than PIL routes absent broader public-law concerns. Courts will not entertain repeat PILs that function as private enforcement tools without broader public impact.
Rajib Agarwala v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee
Rajib Agarwala approached the Gauhati High Court in WP(C) No. 2722 of 2024; judgment dated 7 August 2026. He had filed his GST return for financial year 2018–19 on 23 October 2019 and availed input tax credit on purchases reflected therein. The tax authority later denied the credit, treating the return as belated under the pre-amendment reading of Section 16(4). The issue was whether ITC remained available after retrospective insertion of Section 16(5), which allowed credit where returns for a period were filed on or before 30 November 2021. The court held the petitioner’s filing fell within that extended window, so denial was unsustainable. The impugned order was set aside; outcome in favour of the assessee. Sections 16 and 39 framed the dispute. This editorial summary is not legal advice.
DOT Truckers Ltd. v. Excise and Taxation Officer Faridabad (West) Ward 5 Faridabad
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
DOT Truckers Ltd. approached the Punjab and Haryana High Court (decided 7 August 2026) against GST proceedings where the show cause notice or order-in-original was served only through portal upload, without acknowledgment or reply. The assessee denied effective notice and sought quashing of ex parte liability. Section 169 CGST was central. Relying on Luxmi Traders v. Union Territory of Chandigarh, the court held such portal-only service insufficient to bind the assessee or start limitation for appeal. Proceedings were restored to the show cause notice stage for a proper reply opportunity. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. The decision is another Rohit Kapoor bench application of the Luxmi Traders standard in Haryana, treating unacknowledged electronic upload as non-service until statutory modes or proven receipt exist, without prejudice to the revenue's right to re-adjudicate after valid service.
PR Industries v. Assistant Commissioner ST
In favour of the assessee
PR Industries (Writ Petition No. 22160 of 2026) assailed one composite assessment order covering several tax periods under Section 74. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh (6 August 2026, bench of Jayasurya and Sekhar JJ) held composite determination impermissible under GST law, set aside the order, and permitted separate period-wise orders after due opportunity. All consequential recovery was revoked. Outcome favoured the assessee. Adds to the consistent Andhra Pradesh line on de-compositing multi-year DRC-07 orders. Departments re-initiating must issue discrete notices and respect limitation per period. Summary for professional readers; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-08-06, High Court of Andhra Pradesh recorded in favour of the assessee in WRIT PETITION NO. 22160 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
H.R. Constructions v. Superintendent of Central Tax
In favour of the assessee
H.R. Constructions filed Writ Petition No. 12234 of 2021 before the Andhra Pradesh High Court, decided 6 August 2026, against reversal of input tax credit for financial year 2018-19. Credit was availed in GSTR-3B filed on 20 December 2019 but initially rejected for exceeding the 20 October 2019 deadline under section 16(4) of the CGST Act. Retrospective section 16(5), read with sections 39 and 20 of the IGST Act, extended the permissible availment window to 30 November 2021. The Division Bench held the dealer's claim timely after amendment and set aside the reversal order. Outcome favoured the assessee. Important for legacy FY 2018-19 ITC disputes following Finance Act changes. Chartered accountants should verify GSTR-3B dates against amended limits. Not legal advice.
Shub Conductors LLP v. Joint Commissioner Central Tax Gst Delhi East Delhi
In favour of the revenue
Shub Conductors LLP (W.P. (C) No. 4126 of 2025) sought writ relief against CGST show cause notice issued before SGST action on overlapping periods, citing Section 6(2)(b) bar on parallel proceedings. The High Court of Delhi on 5 August 2026 (Sections 6, 67, 74; Articles 226 and 227) held the bar was not attracted on the facts and jurisdictional objection could not bypass statutory appeal under Section 107. Writ interference was unwarranted; outcome favoured the revenue. Intelligence-driven dual notices require careful analysis of which authority leads and whether Section 6 actually prohibits sequential or overlapping investigation. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-08-05, High Court of Delhi recorded in favour of the revenue in W.P. (C) NO. 4126 OF 2025. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.6, CGST S.74, CGST S.67. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Kumar Manish (Corpus) v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
Kumar Manish filed habeas corpus (Allahabad High Court, HCWP 913 of 2026, 5 August 2026, Siddharth and Vinai Kumar Dwivedi, JJ.) challenging detention following arrest in a CGST input tax credit fraud investigation under Sections 69 and 132. Petitioner emphasized that maximum punishment may extend only up to five years, suggesting arrest should be rare. Respondents demonstrated credible material and recorded reasons per statutory requirements showing arrest necessary to secure effective investigation and prevent continuation of offences or tampering with evidence. The court distinguished bail-stage assessments from habeas scrutiny of initial arrest validity, upholding custody where reasons were contemporaneously documented. Writ dismissed; detention affirmed. Outcome: in favour of the revenue. Reinforces that five-year cap under Section 132 does not automatically bar arrest when Section 69 conditions are met. Informational summary.
Jubilant Avenues (P.) Ltd. v. Superintendent of Central Tax
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Jubilant Avenues (P.) Ltd. assailed a single composite adjudication order under Section 74 for multiple financial years alleging fraud. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh (Writ Petition No. 21486 of 2026, 5 August 2026) held that even in Section 74 proceedings each tax period requires separate adjudication; one composite order could not confirm liability across years. The impugned order was set aside with liberty to pass period-wise orders after due notice and hearing. Outcome: assessee favoured with remand. Aligns with Andhra Pradesh jurisprudence on invalid clubbing of assessment periods. Departments must structure fraud proceedings year-by-year to survive judicial scrutiny. Informational summary for professionals; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-08-05, High Court of Andhra Pradesh recorded in favour of the assessee; matter remanded in WRIT PETITION NO. 21486 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Goel Metal v. Union of India
In favour of the revenue
M/s Goel Metal filed a writ before the Delhi High Court (W.P.(C) 10996/2026, decided 5 August 2026) following search and seizure under Section 67 of the CGST Act and a subsequent show cause notice alleging fraudulent input tax credit and use of fake firms. The petitioner argued that goods seized under Section 67(2) could be released only after determination of liability under Section 74A(9), that the phrase "on a provisional basis" in Section 67(6) was ultra vires where tax, interest and penalty were already paid, and that confiscation or penalty proceedings after Section 74A(9) closure lacked jurisdiction. The Division Bench explained that Section 67 addresses inspection, search, seizure and provisional release on bond or security, while Section 74A governs determination of unpaid, short-paid or erroneously refunded tax and wrongly availed ITC, and the provisions operate in separate fields. Provisional release under Section 67(6) is not contingent on Section 74A(9). The constitutional challenge was not sustained without proof of constitutional breach. On the show cause notice, the court permitted the petitioner to file a reply if advised. The petition was disposed of with observations that favoured the revenue's reading of the statute.
Commissioner CGST & CX v. Power Tech Global (P.) Ltd
See the decision
The GST Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata (Appeal Nos. APL 62, 74 and 75 (KLK) of 2026, 5 August 2026), considered whether MEIS duty scrips should be excluded from the aggregate value of exempt supplies for common credit reversal under Section 17 CGST and Rule 43. For periods before Notification No. 14 of 2022, which amended Rule 43 to exclude duty credit scrip value, the Tribunal treated the amendment as prospective. ITC on concessional schemes could not be claimed retrospectively as a vested right, and Section 74 featured in related demand context. Outcome is nuanced (“see the decision”) on period-wise treatment. CAs allocating common credit should apply pre- and post-notification rules separately and not assume retroactive exclusion of scrip values. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
City Lights and Equipments v. State of Meghalaya
In favour of the revenue
City Lights and Equipments, a firm, invoked the Meghalaya High Court (WP(C) 264 of 2024, 4 August 2026) against demand and assessment orders, alleging bias and natural justice violations because inspection, assessment based on seized estimates, residuary rate application, and reconciliation issues involved overlapping officer roles. Petitioner also raised proper-officer jurisdiction. The court noted an effective remedy before the GST Appellate Tribunal under Section 112, with first appeal under Section 107 already in the chain. No actual bias or clear jurisdictional illegality was demonstrated on writ record; disputed factual questions on seized data and reconciliation were held fit for tribunal evaluation under Article 226’s restraint. The writ was dismissed. Outcome: in favour of the revenue; assessee to pursue GSTAT appeal.
Chehar Industry (P.) Ltd., In re
Chehar Industry (P.) Ltd. approached the Gujarat Authority for Advance Ruling (4 August 2026) as a manufacturer-trader of bar- or cake-form laundry soaps used for washing clothes and textiles, seeking correct HSN classification and GST rate. The bench (Members Malani and Vora) distinguished these products from toilet soaps by composition and end use. It held them classifiable as laundry soaps under sub-heading 34011 and taxable at 18% under Entry No. 66 of Schedule-II to Notification No. 09/2025-Central Tax (Rate) dated 17 September 2025, read with Sections 9 and 10 CGST on levy and composition where relevant. The ruling gives CAs a clear product-based line between laundry and toilet soap categories for rate purposes. Facts are limited to the applicant’s stated manufacturing pattern; other formulations may need separate rulings.
Manoj Bansal v. Deputy Director, Directorate of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence
In favour of the assessee
Manoj Bansal filed CRM-M No. 45265 of 2025 before the Punjab & Haryana High Court; judgment 1 August 2026. A complaint under Section 132 alleged wrongful availment of input tax credit by M/s NIPL but arraigned only Bansal as director, not the company. Section 137 CGST makes officers liable only when the company, as registered person, commits an offence and is prosecuted. Vicarious prosecution cannot proceed if the principal accused company is absent from the charge sheet. The court quashed the complaint and all consequential proceedings. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Important for directors facing standalone prosecution. Not legal advice. Compliance teams should ensure company name appears on complaints before director liability is pursued under Section 137. The ruling protects directors from standalone criminal exposure when prosecution omits the registered entity.
Vasanta Resorts and Spa (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Vasanta Resorts and Spa (P.) Ltd. filed CWP No. 12966 of 2026 before the Himachal Pradesh High Court; order 31 July 2026. The dispute concerned input tax credit blocked or denied following retrospective amendment to Section 17(5)(d), which restricts credit on construction of immovable property. The assessee filed a belated appeal; the Appellate Authority dismissed it as time-barred and declined condonation beyond the statutory limit in Section 107. The High Court set aside the dismissal on delay grounds alone and remanded the appeal for adjudication on merits of the Section 17(5)(d) challenge. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. CAs should separate limitation issues from substantive ITC blocking under Section 17. Not legal advice. Merits will now include whether hospitality construction qualifies for any exception under the amended Section 17(5)(d) language.
Sagar Ghosh v. Deputy Commissioner, State GST
In favour of the assessee; matter remanded
Sagar Ghosh (W.P.A. No. 1197 of 2026) raised pure jurisdictional questions—competence and cross-empowerment—against adjudication, appellate, and recovery steps under Section 74, without disputed facts. The High Court of Calcutta on 31 July 2026 held the writ maintainable despite an alternate remedy where only legal issues were involved, and remanded to the adjudicating authority to decide jurisdiction first. Outcome: assessee favoured with remand. Useful precedent when challenging officer designation or dual jurisdiction at the threshold rather than on ITC merits. Jurisdictional defects may be agitated in writ when fact-finding is unnecessary. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-07-31, High Court of Calcutta recorded in favour of the assessee; matter remanded in W.P.A. NO. 1197 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.
Gaurav Jain v. Joint Commissioner (Appeals-II) CGST Delhi Zone
In favour of the assessee
Gaurav Jain petitioned the Delhi High Court (W.P.(C) No. 8414 of 2026, 31 July 2026) after appellate authorities demanded 10% pre-deposit for penalty-only appeals linked to Section 122(1A) SCNs issued before the substituted proviso to Section 107(6) CGST and Rule 108. The Court held the appeal right vested at SCN issuance and pre-amended law governed, so the 10% pre-deposit requirement did not apply to those penalty appeals. Outcome favoured the assessee. Aligns with Delhi jurisprudence on non-retroactive pre-deposit for legacy penalty notices. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.
Er. Roland S. v. Government of Karnataka
In favour of the assessee
Er. Roland S., a Class-I civil contractor, filed before the Karnataka High Court (WP 105716/2026, 30 July 2026) seeking reimbursement of differential GST paid on government works awarded before GST replaced VAT. Sections 142 and 9 CGST and transition principles applied. Having executed state contracts and remitted incremental tax after transition, the petitioner acquired a legal right to reimbursement of differential liability attributable to GST introduction, with the State as recipient of works contract services bound by earlier rulings. The court directed verification and reimbursement of the differential confined to incremental GST transition impact, not unrelated tax increases. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Pre-GST government contractors in Karnataka may rely on this for recovery of transition-related tax from departments subject to proof of payment and contract terms.
S.K. Swamy and Company, In re
In favour of the revenue
S.K. Swamy and Company, a registered Karnataka partnership, sought an advance ruling (Order KAR.ADRG/42/2026, 29 July 2026) on whether its activity of supplying ballast and loading it into Railway wagons using JCB loaders constituted a works contract under GST. The Karnataka AAR (Members Rama Rao and Itagi) found no building, construction, erection, or work connected with immovable property; the engagement was essentially supply and loading of goods for rail transport. Accordingly the arrangement could not be classified as a works contract under the statutory definition in Section 2 CGST, with implications for tax treatment under Sections 8 and 9. Outcome favoured revenue’s view that works-contract classification was unavailable. Contractors performing similar loading-only services should analyse immovable-property nexus separately; this summary is not legal advice.
Executive Engineer v. M. Venkata Rao Infra Projects (P.) Ltd
See the decision
The Executive Engineer filed a writ appeal before the Karnataka High Court (WA 1947/2025, 29 July 2026) concerning withholding of differential GST on municipal works executed under the earlier VAT and service tax regime. Sections 142 and 9 CGST and Article 226 were raised. M. Venkata Rao Infra Projects had invoked arbitration under the contract, covering the reimbursement claim for transition tax. The Division Bench held the writ under Article 226 not maintainable where an arbitration clause exists and arbitral proceedings are pending, without adjudicating reimbursement merits on the writ side. Outcome: procedural dismissal of writ route. Contractors must pursue contractual arbitration rather than parallel writs when arbitration already covers GST differential claims, though Er. Roland S. remains relevant where no arbitration bar exists.
DG Anti Profiteering, Director General of Anti-Profiteering, DGAP v. Maata Rani Builders and Developers
In favour of the revenue
In NAPA No. 54 (PB) of 2025 (29 July 2026), the GST Appellate Tribunal at New Delhi confirmed anti-profiteering liability of Maata Rani Builders and Developers for the Anamika Apartment project. Under Section 171 CGST and Rule 133, benefit of additional ITC must reduce prices to recipients. The builder offered some extra construction free of cost but did not reflect the ITC benefit as an actual price reduction on flats. The Tribunal accepted the DGAP’s computation and methodology, holding the developer liable to pass on Rs 99,435 with applicable GST and interest to affected homebuyers. Outcome favoured revenue. Freebies or add-on work do not substitute for the statutory pass-through of ITC benefit; quantification followed DGAP’s accepted approach. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.