Every ruling, in plain sight

Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.

278 rulings

High Court of ChhattisgarhRegistration

Morvi Nandan Healthcare (P.) Ltd. v. State of Chhattisgarh

In favour of the assessee

Morvi Nandan Healthcare (P.) Ltd. obtained relief from the Chhattisgarh High Court (17 August 2026, WPT No. 179 of 2025) where registration was cancelled for alleged non-operation at the declared place of business following field verification. The Form GST REG-17 show-cause notice omitted the date and time for personal hearing as contemplated under Rules 21 and 22, depriving the company of a clear opportunity to present its case. The Court held this breached natural justice and invalidated the notice and cancellation order, observing that procedural fairness cannot be sacrificed even where an alternative statutory remedy might exist under Section 29. Both the SCN and cancellation were quashed with liberty to the department to proceed afresh in accordance with law after issuing a compliant notice. Outcome: assessee-favourable. The decision stresses procedural completeness in REG-17 notices before adverse registration action. Summary only; not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST Rules R.21CGST Rules R.22
High Court of Andhra PradeshAssessment

Sri Vijaya Traders v. Assistant Commissioner of State Taxes

In favour of the assessee

Sri Vijaya Traders (Andhra Pradesh High Court, WP 23181 of 2026, 14 August 2026) failed to file GSTR-3B for March 2025 prompting Section 62 assessment. Dealer later filed return, paying tax with late fee under Section 47 and interest under Section 50. Issue was whether assessment survived belated compliance. Court held Section 62(2) operates to deem assessment withdrawn upon filing return and paying tax; consequential coercive proceedings tied to Section 62 order revoked. Liability for interest and late fee nonetheless continues independently. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Practical lesson: post-Section 62 compliance remains valuable remedial step for registered dealers facing best-judgment orders. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice. Material facts and holdings are drawn from the reported judgment.

CGST S.62CGST S.47CGST S.50
High Court of MadrasTransitional Provisions

Plus Max Duty Free (Kovai) (P.) Ltd. v. State Tax Officer

In favour of the assessee

Plus Max Duty Free (Kovai) (P.) Ltd. filed before the Madras High Court (WP 25986 and 25991/2026, 14 August 2026) for refund of service tax paid on licence fees and conservancy charges at airport duty-free outlets under the pre-GST regime, after claims were rejected as time-barred despite a favourable CESTAT ruling. Section 142 CGST, Finance Act 1994 Section 83 and Central Excise Sections 11B and 11BB framed transitional refund. Following binding Division Bench precedent in Union of India v. Flemingo Duty Free Shop (P.) Ltd., refunds were directed to be processed with applicable interest rather than dismissed on limitation alone. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Duty-free operators may pursue legacy service tax refunds post-GST transition when Flemingo lineage applies to airport concession payments.

CGST S.142Finance Act 1994 S.83Central Excise S.11BCentral Excise S.11BB
High Court of ChhattisgarhWrits Constitutional Remedies

Bhartiya Caterers and Enterprises v. State Bank of India

See the decision

Bhartiya Caterers and Enterprises filed before the Chhattisgarh High Court (WPC 4234/2026, 14 August 2026) against State Bank of India after its meal-supply tender bid was rejected despite quoting identical rates to another bidder, amid GST ambiguity on the contract. CGST Section 9 and Articles 226 and 14 were invoked. Post-bid offers and delay or unpaid-dues allegations did not establish illegality, arbitrariness or breach of tender terms. Judicial review under Article 226 ensures fair process, not merits revision or contract re-writing. The writ was dismissed on limited constitutional review grounds without examining whether GST inclusion affected rate comparability. Outcome: no relief on tender merits. GST practitioners advising on government tenders should separate tax clarification disputes from Article 226 challenges unless procedural unfairness is clearly shown.

CGST S.9Constitution Art.226Constitution Art.14
High Court of Andhra PradeshDemands Adjudication

v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax

In favour of the assessee

M/s. GMR A Shaha Iron Steels, a registered firm, filed Writ Petition No. 22817 of 2026 before the Andhra Pradesh High Court, decided 13 August 2026, against a composite assessment order in Form GST DRC-07 for financial years 2020-21 through 2023-24 under section 73 of the CGST Act. Relying on coordinate bench precedent, the Court held that a single composite order covering multiple tax periods is impermissible because it impairs statutory appeal rights and related reliefs under sections 73 and 75. The impugned order was set aside on this ground alone; other grounds of challenge were left open. Respondents were permitted to initiate fresh period-wise proceedings, subject to conditions including deposit of twenty per cent of disputed tax within six weeks. The outcome favoured the assessee. Not legal advice.

CGST S.73CGST S.75
High Court of KarnatakaLevy Collection

Smt. Lalitha S. v. Deputy Commissioner

In favour of the assessee

Smt. Lalitha S. filed Writ Petition No. 24040 of 2026 (LA-RES) before the Karnataka High Court; order 13 August 2026. Compensation for compulsory acquisition of land with an attached structure for highway widening was paid through the Deputy Commissioner, who deducted GST from the award. The petitioner challenged the deduction as ultra vires. The court held compulsory acquisition is not a supply of goods or services under GST; no statutory authority permits charging GST on expropriation compensation. Deduction was invalid and refund directed. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Sections 7 and 9 CGST and Article 366 were discussed. CAs advising on acquisition awards should note this limitation on GST levy. Not legal advice. Acquisition authorities must gross up compensation without treating GST as a deductible element unless a specific taxable supply exists.

CGST S.9CGST S.7Constitution Art.366
High Court of CalcuttaAppellate Authority

Kulik Plywood (P.) Ltd. v. State of West Bengal

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Kulik Plywood Pvt. Ltd. succeeded before the Calcutta High Court (WPA No. 7650 of 2026, 13 August 2026) where the SCN was visible only under “Additional Notice and Orders” on the GST portal without separate intimation under Section 169 CGST, preventing timely response. The Section 107 appeal was dismissed on limitation without merit review. The Court quashed the appellate order and directed admission and merits hearing. Outcome favoured the assessee with remand, consistent with Dutta on portal-only communication and natural justice. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107CGST S.169
High Court of PatnaRefund

KPIL-JWIL Joint Venture v. State of Bihar

See the decision

KPIL-JWIL Joint Venture, a Munger-registered works contractor, filed a writ before the Patna High Court (CWJC No. 5398 of 2026, decided 13 August 2026) against a deficiency memo in Form GST RFD-03 dated 1 March 2025 proposing rejection of Rs. 1.75 crore refund from its electronic cash ledger under Section 54 read with Rule 90. An earlier refund rejection based on alleged ineligible input tax credit had been set aside on appeal; revenue filed revision and later an appeal before GSTAT. The assessee argued Section 54(11) barred withholding refund during tribunal appeal unless the Commissioner passed a reasoned withholding order after hearing. No such order existed. The court disposed the writ directing the Commissioner to issue show cause, grant personal hearing, and pass a reasoned Section 54(11) order within stipulated timelines.

CGST S.54CGST Rules R.90
High Court of DelhiExemptions

Kanwal Chaudhary v. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India

In favour of the revenue

Kanwal Chaudhary, an Advocate enrolled as an Insolvency Professional, challenged GST treatment before the Delhi High Court in W.P.(C) No. 9410 of 2021, decided 13 August 2026. The dispute concerned insolvency resolution and receivership services performed after NCLT appointment, as distinct from pure legal representation. The Court held such IP services are not "legal services" for reverse charge under section 9 read with section 11 of the CGST Act. The professional must obtain GST registration, charge tax on forward charge, and issue compliant tax invoices. Services rendered strictly as Advocate continue under reverse charge. IBC section 16 was distinguished where relevant. Revenue prevailed on classification, affecting compliance templates for IPs. This summary is for professional awareness only and is not legal advice.

CGST S.11CGST S.9IBC S.16
High Court of DelhiService Of Notices Orders

A 1 Enterprises v. Sales Tax Officer Class II/ Avato

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

A 1 Enterprises filed a writ before the Delhi High Court (W.P.(C) 11634/2026, 13 August 2026) impugning a show cause notice and order under Section 73 CGST on the ground that both were served only by uploading on the GST portal, without proof of actual intimation or receipt, and that no reply had been filed in ignorance. The revenue relied on Section 169 on deemed service through the common portal. The court held that portal-only service without acknowledgement or evidence of receipt is insufficient where the assessee denies effective notice, following the approach in Luxmi Traders on meaningful service for proceedings with serious civil consequences. The impugned order was set aside and the assessee was granted opportunity to file a reply to the show cause notice. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand to the adjudication stage. The case reinforces that electronic upload alone does not dispense with the revenue's obligation to establish valid service under Section 169 when the taxpayer had no real opportunity to respond.

CGST S.169CGST S.73
High Court of KarnatakaArrest Bail

Venkatasubbaiah C v. Superintendent of Central Tax

In favour of the assessee

Partners operating a battery recycling firm (Karnataka High Court, Criminal Petition 9023 of 2026, 12 August 2026, S. Vishwajith Shetty, J.) sought anticipatory bail amid allegations of fictitious suppliers, bogus ITC and untraceable vendors under Sections 69 and 132 CGST. Revenue argued supplier cancellations proved fraud; petitioners maintained valid registration, documented purchases, and no collusion. Court noted post-supply cancellation of supplier GSTIN without collusion evidence does not automatically deny recipient ITC, especially where recipients cooperated and lacked antecedents. Offences being compoundable with five-year maximum, custodial interrogation was unnecessary at this stage. Anticipatory bail granted on conditions. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Highlights ITC defence themes when supplier compliance fails after transaction. Editorial summary. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.69CGST S.132
High Court of DelhiOther

Siemens Healthcare (P). Ltd. v. Union of India

In favour of the revenue

Siemens Healthcare (P) Ltd. approached the High Court of Delhi (W.P. (C) No. 16562 of 2024, decided 12 August 2026) to restrain transfer of its audit file from the Audit Wing to the Anti-Evasion Wing within the same commissionerate. The taxpayer cited lack of statutory authority and disruption of audit timelines under Section 65 of the CGST Act. The court treated the transfer as an internal administrative reallocation, not barred by statute, particularly where it followed repeated non-compliance by the petitioner in responding to audit requisitions. Judicial interference at the writ stage was unwarranted; the petitioner could raise jurisdictional and procedural objections before the adjudicating authority in the consequential proceedings. The petition was dismissed in favour of the revenue. Section 5 empowers reallocation of work among officers without invalidating subsequent enforcement.

CGST S.5CGST S.65
High Court of DelhiRegistration

SGS Export (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Tax /GST Delhi

In favour of the assessee

SGS Export (P.) Ltd. won before the Delhi High Court (12 August 2026, W.P.(C) No. 12260 of 2025) on the ground that a notice proposing cancellation of registration was only uploaded on the GST portal without proof of receipt, acknowledgement or service through any other mode recognized under the CGST framework. The company learned of cancellation only when its compliance chain broke, and its restoration application was rejected as time-barred. The Court held that mere portal upload did not amount to valid service under Section 29 read with Section 169. The petitioner was entitled to apply for restoration, and that application must be decided on merits without being rejected solely for limitation flowing from defective service. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Clarifies limits of portal upload as service for registration SCNs. Not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST S.169
High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and LadakhInput Tax Credit

NCC Ltd. v. Union Territory of J & K

In favour of the assessee

NCC Ltd., engaged in construction, filed WP(C) No. 1935 of 2026 before the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh, decided on 12 August 2026. The Additional Commissioner had blocked the company’s electronic credit ledger under CGST Rule 86A, linked to Section 49, without stating reasons or offering a prior hearing. The revenue argued Rule 86A does not mandate a show-cause. The court disagreed: blocking input tax credit affects substantive rights and carries serious civil consequences, so principles of natural justice and audi alteram partem apply even when the rule is silent on procedure. The order was held arbitrary and set aside. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. For chartered accountants reviewing ITC blocks, the decision underscores that administrative power under Rule 86A must be exercised fairly and transparently. This summary is for professional awareness and is not legal advice.

CGST S.49CGST Rules R.86A
High Court of UttarakhandService Of Notices Orders

Winstrol Petrochemicals (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner, State GST

In favour of the assessee

Winstrol Petrochemicals (P.) Ltd. challenged Uttarakhand GST adjudication (WP 3695/2024, 11 August 2026) where the show cause notice was uploaded only on the portal after registration cancellation, without alternate modes under Section 169 or personal hearing under Section 73. The demand included tax, interest and penalty determined ex parte. The court held a cancelled registrant is not obliged to monitor the portal; portal-only service was invalid and failure to grant hearing rendered the adjudication order unsustainable. The order was quashed with liberty to the department to proceed after lawful service. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Combined with Ayaz Traders, Uttarakhand law now clearly rejects post-cancellation portal-only demands absent email, registered post or other prescribed service modes under Section 169.

CGST S.169CGST S.73
High Court of UttarakhandService Of Notices Orders

Gajendra Singh Cont. v. Assistant Commissioner

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

In a contempt-related writ before the Uttarakhand High Court (WP 647/2026, 11 August 2026), Gajendra Singh challenged an adjudication order passed after cancellation of registration, without personal hearing as mandated by Section 75(4) CGST and with notice served only via portal post-cancellation. The demand related to tax, interest and penalty determined without the petitioner participating. Sections 169, 73 and 75 governed service and hearing. The court quashed the order and directed fresh adjudication after granting proper personal hearing in accordance with law, including valid service where registration no longer required portal monitoring. Outcome: in favour of the assessee with remand. The ruling integrates cancelled-registration service law with mandatory personal hearing under Section 75, preventing ex parte demands where both defects coexist and reinforcing Uttarakhand's approach in Winstrol and Ayaz Traders.

CGST S.169CGST S.73CGST S.75
High Court of DelhiService Of Notices Orders

Absolute Electrovision (P.) Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner, CGST Delhi East

In favour of the assessee

Absolute Electrovision (P.) Ltd. challenged adjudication under Section 74 CGST before the Delhi High Court (W.P.(C) 6593/2025, 11 August 2026), alleging that the show cause notice was never duly served, depriving it of a chance to reply, and that liability was presumed without valid service. The writ court confined itself to validity of service and limitation, deferring merits of the demand. Section 169 and the principles in Luxmi Traders v. Union Territory of Chandigarh were applied to assess whether portal or other modes constituted effective service. Where service failed statutory and judicial standards, ex parte adjudication could not stand. The petition was allowed in favour of the assessee. Practitioners should treat this as part of a consistent Delhi High Court line requiring the department to prove more than bare portal upload when disputing receipt. The decision does not adjudicate ITC or fraud merits but restores procedural fairness at the notice stage.

CGST S.169CGST S.74
High Court of KarnatakaInput Tax Credit

Shakti Enterprises v. Principal Commissioner of Central Tax

In favour of the assessee

Shakti Enterprises filed Writ Petition No. 1913 of 2026 (T-RES) before the Karnataka High Court; judgment 10 August 2026. On transition to GST the petitioner carried forward valid CENVAT credit into its electronic credit ledger under Section 140 and later debited that ledger to satisfy the pre-deposit required to pursue an appeal under Section 107. The Appellate Tribunal rejected the appeal, treating the pre-deposit as invalid because it was not paid in cash, relying on CBIC administrative instructions. The High Court held the statute does not restrict pre-deposit to cash when credit in the Section 49 ledger is lawfully available; circulars cannot override statutory credit rights or Rule 142 procedures. The Tribunal’s ground of rejection was quashed. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Not legal advice.

CGST S.140CGST S.49CGST S.107CGST Rules R.142
High Court of UttarakhandRegistration

Dhingra Glass v. Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax

In favour of the assessee

Before the Uttarakhand High Court (10 August 2026, Writ Petition Misc. Bench No. 280 of 2026), Dhingra Glass challenged cancellation of its GST registration and an appellate dismissal confined to limitation. The assessee offered to file all outstanding returns and pay tax, interest and penalty in full. The issue was whether writ relief could open a path to revocation despite the missed appellate timeline. The Court reasoned that where the appeal failed only on delay and substantive compliance was forthcoming, the statutory scheme for cancellation and restoration under Sections 29 and 30 and Rule 23 should still be accessible. Outcome: decided in favour of the assessee—the petitioner was granted liberty to apply for revocation after compliance, with a direction that the authority decide that application on merits in accordance with law. Key provisions: CGST Sections 29 and 30 and Rule 23. Editorial summary for practitioners; not legal advice.

CGST S.30CGST S.29CGST Rules R.23
High Court of DelhiRecovery Attachment

Zubair Enterprises v. Commissioner CGST and Central Excise

In favour of the assessee

Zubair Enterprises approached the High Court of Delhi (W.P.(C) No. 18468 of 2025, decided 7 August 2026) seeking de-freezing of bank accounts provisionally attached under Section 83 of the CGST Act. More than one year had elapsed since the attachment order was issued. The court held that provisional attachment ceases by operation of Section 83(2) after the statutory period unless validly extended in accordance with law. Accounts must be released when no fresh valid order exists. The competent authority was directed to record the one-year cap on the file and banks were to de-freeze automatically after expiry. The outcome favoured the assessee, consistent with Delhi High Court practice on Section 83 time limits post Kesari Nandan Mobile. This editorial summary is not legal advice.

CGST S.83