Every ruling, in plain sight

Look up GST High Court, GSTAT, and advance-ruling decisions by topic — with a complete summary for each matter and the source judgment PDF when you need the full text.

278 rulings

High Court of GauhatiRegistration

Smt. Jumoni Boruah Phukan v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Smt. Jumoni Boruah Phukan filed writ in the Gauhati High Court (12 June 2026, WP(C) No. 3071 of 2026) after cancellation of her GST registration for six months’ continuous non-filing of returns; she cited financial hardship while expressing readiness to comply with the proviso to Rule 22(4) by filing all pending returns and clearing dues. The issue was whether cancellation under Section 29(2)(c) should permanently exclude a bona fide taxpayer willing to cure the default. Applying Sections 30, 44, 73 and Rule 22, the Court granted restoration subject to compliance, directed that fresh limitation periods run from the order, and confirmed full liability for tax, interest, penalty and late fee. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Aligns with Gauhati line on curing return defaults after Section 29(2)(c) cancellation. Not legal advice.

CGST S.30CGST S.44CGST S.73CGST Rules R.22
High Court of MadrasDemands Adjudication

KPR Enterprises v. State Tax Officer

In favour of the revenue

KPR Enterprises, engaged in rock boulder sales, challenged extended limitation and procedure before the High Court of Madras (W.P. Nos. 35453, 35458 and 35463 of 2024, 12 June 2026). Revenue compared declared turnover with high seigniorage fee payments and estimated escaped turnover using the National Standard Method, justifying notice under Section 74 read with Section 75. The court found prima facie material supported invocation of fraud/suppression limitation and dismissed the writ as meritless. Outcome favoured the revenue. The case illustrates how non-GST records (mining/seigniorage data) may underpin GST demand in quarrying businesses. Appeal under Section 107 remains the appropriate further forum for detailed challenge. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-06-12, High Court of Madras recorded in favour of the revenue in W.P. NOS. 35453, 35458 AND 35463 OF 2024. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74, CGST S.75. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.74CGST S.75
High Court of KarnatakaRegistration

Flex Enterprises v. Superintendent of Central Tax

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

In Flex Enterprises v. Superintendent of Central Tax, the Karnataka High Court (12 June 2026, Writ Petition Nos. 13708 and 13791 of 2026) examined bulk cancellation of registrations based on show-cause notices under Rule 22(1) tied to inspection reports that were blank or defective. The issue was whether the precondition for issuing a valid SCN under Section 29 and Rules 21A and 22 was met. The Court found it was not: without credible inspection material, the SCN and consequent cancellation and suspension could not stand. Orders were quashed and proceedings restored to the SCN stage so petitioners could respond with documents. Outcome: assessee-favourable remand. The decision underscores that registration cancellation must rest on proper fact-finding, not pro forma notices. Summary for Chartered Accountants; not legal advice.

CGST S.29CGST Rules R.21ACGST Rules R.22
High Court of GauhatiDemands Adjudication

Debojit Deb v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Debojit Deb (Gauhati High Court, WP(C) 1653 of 2026, 12 June 2026, Kardak Ete, J.) executed government works contracts claiming service tax exemption under applicable notification while department raised demand referencing only Income-tax Form 26AS entries without independent verification or recording prerequisites for extended limitation under Finance Act 1994 Sections 73, 75, 77 and 78. Transition to GST via Section 142 did not cure jurisdictional defect in adjudication approach. Demand lacked substantiation beyond third-party tax deduction data. Court set aside order as unauthorized assumption of jurisdiction. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Pre-GST service tax disputes illustrate limits of 26AS-only adjudication. Editorial summary for Chartered Universe; not legal advice. This editorial note is for Chartered Universe professional research and is not legal advice.

Finance Act 1994 S.73Finance Act 1994 S.75Finance Act 1994 S.77Finance Act 1994 S.78+1 more
High Court of KarnatakaDetention In Transit

Vishal Singh v. Commercial Tax Officer (Enforcement)-25) (South Zone)

In favour of the assessee

Vishal Singh challenged detention of goods and conveyance before the Karnataka High Court in Writ Petition No. 15125 of 2026 (T-RES), decided 11 June 2026. Enforcement officials had detained the shipment citing quantity mismatch between documents and physical verification. The assessee had paid penalty pursuant to an appellate order while the revenue's suo motu revision remained pending under section 108 of the CGST Act. Invoking sections 129 and 130 read with Article 226, the Court directed protective release of goods subject to deposit of appropriate securities until the revision was finally decided. The arrangement balanced coercive detention powers against the assessee's commercial need to move stock. Outcome favoured the assessee. Useful precedent for interim relief during parallel revision proceedings. Not legal advice.

CGST S.129CGST S.108CGST S.130Constitution Art.226
High Court of MadrasInput Tax Credit

TVL. Alpha Tech v. Deputy Commercial Tax Officer

In favour of the assessee

TVL. Alpha Tech filed WP No. 20859 of 2026 before the Madras High Court; judgment 11 June 2026 on input tax credit. The Deputy Commercial Tax Officer denied ITC because GSTR-3B for the disputed periods was filed late. The sole issue before the court was whether delay alone could sustain denial after the law was amended to insert Section 16(5), extending the date for filing returns and claiming credit to 30 November 2021 for eligible periods. The petitioner filed within that window. The court held rejection based exclusively on pre-amendment delay was untenable and set aside the impugned order. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Sections 16 and 39 govern return filing and credit entitlement. Chartered accountants should map client filing dates against Section 16(5) before accepting ITC denials. Not legal advice.

CGST S.16CGST S.39
High Court of CalcuttaAppellate Authority

GSPR Developers (P.) Ltd. v. State of West Bengal

In favour of the assessee

GSPR Developers Pvt. Ltd. approached the Calcutta High Court (WPA No. 263 of 2026, 11 June 2026) after its Section 107 appeal was dismissed as time-barred. The adjudication order had been communicated only to its accountant, who failed to inform the company, delay surfacing when recovery began; pre-deposit had been paid. Das De J condoned delay for sufficient cause and directed admission of the appeal. Outcome favoured the assessee. Internal communication failures by agents may constitute sufficient cause for condonation when combined with compliance on pre-deposit. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107CGST S.79
High Court of KarnatakaDemands Adjudication

State of Karnataka v. Sudhanva Engineers and Builders A Sole Proprietorship

In favour of the revenue

In Writ Appeal No. 718 of 2025, decided by the Karnataka High Court on 10 June 2026, the State challenged directions that would require GST authorities to permit revised returns and waive interest, penalty, or limitation for a contractor seeking reimbursement of incremental GST on a government works contract. The contractor had argued contractual entitlement to pass-through of post-GST tax; the appellate bench held that reimbursement of tax paid or payable after 1 July 2017 is strictly a dispute between contractor and employer under their agreement. Statutory liability under section 9 and allied CGST provisions cannot be reshaped by contract, and courts cannot direct tax authorities to waive compliance timelines or limitation. Sections 73 and 108 were discussed in that context. The appeal favoured the revenue by confining contractual reimbursement to the employer relationship. Not legal advice.

CGST S.73CGST S.9CGST S.108
High Court of KarnatakaReturns

State of Karnataka v. Sudhanva Engineers and Builders

In favour of the revenue

The Karnataka High Court Division Bench (10 June 2026, Writ Appeal No. 275 of 2025) allowed the State’s appeal against a Single Judge order that had directed relaxed penalty, interest or limitation for Sudhanva Engineers and Builders, a works contractor, to file or amend GST returns based on a reimbursement clause in its government contract. The contractor argued the employer would reimburse GST consequences, but the revenue contended courts cannot soften statutory fiscal obligations by contract. Under Sections 39, 37, 50, 128 and 168A, contractual reimbursement cannot override mandatory GST statutory liability for returns, interest and penalty; nor can writ courts direct relaxation of statutory limitation or condonation in the absence of valid statutory power. Outcome: in favour of the revenue—the impugned assessee-favourable relief was unsustainable. Not legal advice.

CGST S.39CGST S.37CGST S.50CGST S.128+1 more
High CourtGovernment Contractors

State of Karnataka Department of Finance v. Unique Constructions

The State of Karnataka filed Writ Appeal No. 615 of 2025 before the Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court, decided 10 June 2026, against a single-judge order directing reimbursement of differential GST to contractors including Unique Constructions. Contractors executed government works contracts priced inclusive of pre-GST taxes but sought pass-through of GST levied after 1 July 2017 on balance work. The appellate Court held reimbursement is strictly contractual between employer and contractor; section 9 CGST liability cannot be modified by writ directions waiving interest, penalty, limitation, or mandating revised returns before tax authorities. Directions binding GST authorities were set aside while employer-only reimbursement directions were clarified. Appeal largely favoured the revenue. Important for government contractor billing post-GST. Not legal advice.

CGST S.9
High Court of GauhatiRegistration

Sri Chongtham Manabandra Singh v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Sri Chongtham Manabandra Singh, a proprietorship assessee, filed writ before the Gauhati High Court (10 June 2026, WP (C) No. 3000 of 2026) against cancellation of GST registration for six months’ continuous non-filing of returns and against appellate rejection of his restoration plea. He offered to comply with the proviso to Rule 22(4) by filing pending returns and paying tax, interest, penalty and late fee. The Court permitted restoration on that basis, directed that statutory limitation under Sections 29, 30, 44 and 73 run from the order date, and required the proper officer to consider restoration expeditiously once compliance is shown. Outcome: in favour of the assessee. Follows the Gauhati line treating return default as curable where cancellation is under Section 29(2)(c). Not legal advice.

CGST S.30CGST S.29CGST S.44CGST S.73+1 more
High Court of KarnatakaDemands Adjudication

Nuvteq Solutions (P.) Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals-5)

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Nuvteq Solutions (P.) Ltd. challenged denial of export-of-services refund before the High Court of Karnataka (Writ Petition No. 16115 of 2026, 10 June 2026). Adjudication and appellate orders rejected eligibility solely for alleged non-furnishing of Letter of Undertaking under Section 54 and Rule 96A, without examining transaction nature or whether LUT was in fact furnished. Both orders were quashed and remanded for fresh consideration of jurisdiction and refund entitlement based on actual LUT compliance and export evidence. Outcome: assessee favoured with remand. Export service providers should maintain LUT filings and reconcile with refund rejections on merits, not bare procedural labels. Not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-06-10, High Court of Karnataka recorded in favour of the assessee; matter remanded in WRIT PETITION NO. 16115 OF 2026 (T-RES). Central provisions engaged included CGST S.73, CGST S.54, CGST Rules R.96A. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.73CGST S.54CGST Rules R.96A
High Court of GauhatiRegistration

Ganpati Rice Mill v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Ganpati Rice Mill, a registered proprietorship, filed writ before the Gauhati High Court (10 June 2026, WP(C) No. 3046 of 2026) against GST registration cancellation for non-filing of returns and failure to respond after suspension. The question was whether restoration remained available upon belated compliance. Following Section 29, Section 30 and Rule 22, the Court held that a taxpayer may seek restoration by furnishing pending returns and paying outstanding tax, interest, penalty and late fee; upon such compliance the proper officer must consider restoration per applicable rules. The petition was disposed of in favour of the assessee with directions to the authority to process restoration in line with prior Gauhati precedents on Rule 22(4). This summary is for professional awareness only and is not legal advice.

CGST S.30CGST S.29CGST Rules R.22
High Court of KarnatakaRecovery Attachment

Commissioner of Central Tax v. Sadguru Infratech (P.) Ltd

In favour of the revenue

The Commissioner of Central Tax appealed before the High Court of Karnataka (Writ Appeal No. 1076 of 2023, decided 10 June 2026) against a Single Judge order favouring Sadguru Infratech (P) Ltd. A sub-contractor had filed GST returns belatedly; garnishee action under Section 79 sought recovery of interest on delayed tax payment under Sections 39 and 50. The Single Judge had permitted filing or amendments of returns post 1 July 2017 without insisting on interest, penalty, or limitation and had restrained recovery. The Division Bench held that interest liability arises by statutory mandate under Section 9 read with Section 50 and cannot be waived or reduced in the absence of a specific enabling provision; Section 128 did not apply. The appeal was allowed in favour of the revenue.

CGST S.79CGST S.39CGST S.50CGST S.128+1 more
High Court of MadrasPenalty

Sri Nav Visw Ratna Industries v. Commercial Tax Officer

In favour of the assessee

Sri Nav Visw Ratna Industries petitioned the High Court of Madras (W.P. No. 19778 of 2026, decided 9 June 2026) against penalty and late fee for delayed filing of the annual return under Section 44. The delay was substantial (995 days). The statute prescribes late fee under Section 47 for that default; a separate general penalty under Section 125 for the same default was held impermissible as duplicative of the specific statutory consequence. Late fee was upheld on facts; the penalty component was set aside. The outcome favoured the assessee. Chartered accountants advising on annual return compliance should note that specific late fee generally exhausts the sanction for that default absent distinct contraventions. This editorial summary is not legal advice.

CGST S.125CGST S.44CGST S.47
High Court of BombayDemands Adjudication

Rithwik Projects (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India

In favour of the assessee

Rithwik Projects (P.) Ltd., a construction company, challenged consolidated show cause notice and composite order demanding GST, interest, and penalty for multiple years. The High Court of Bombay (Writ Petition No. 4061 of 2026, 9 June 2026) under Section 74 held clubbing of periods beyond statutory jurisdiction; assessments must be period-specific. Consolidated notice, order, and recovery were void ab initio and not cured by admission or estoppel; writ was maintainable. All impugned actions were quashed. Outcome favoured the assessee. Bombay High Court joins other forums in rejecting composite fraud proceedings across FYs. Construction sector audits often span multiple years—periodisation is critical. Informational; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-06-09, High Court of Bombay recorded in favour of the assessee in WRIT PETITION NO. 4061 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.74. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.74
High Court of CalcuttaDemands Adjudication

ISC Processors (P.) Ltd. v. Superintendent Burrabazar Division, Kolkata North

In favour of the revenue

ISC Processors (P.) Ltd. filed a writ under Article 226 against a show cause notice, citing lack of jurisdiction and bona fide GST-paid purchases, while the department alleged supplies from non-existent vendors and ineligible ITC. The High Court of Calcutta (WPA No. 10744 of 2026, 9 June 2026), applying Section 75, declined interference because only a notice existed and full statutory adjudication—including reply and hearing—remained available. The petitioner was directed to respond and the authority to adjudicate after hearing both sides. Outcome favoured the revenue in the sense that the writ was not entertained on merits at the pre-adjudication stage. Residual disputes are for the adjudication and appeal chain. Informational summary; not legal advice. Disposed on 2026-06-09, High Court of Calcutta recorded in favour of the revenue in WPA NO. 10744 OF 2026. Central provisions engaged included CGST S.75, Constitution Art.226. Chartered accountants should map period-wise limitation, personal hearing, and appeal under Section 107 when advising on replies, deposits, or writ versus appeal strategy. This editorial summary is for professional research and is not legal advice.

CGST S.75Constitution Art.226
High Court of KarnatakaService Of Notices Orders

GVS Engineering and Construction v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes

See the decision

GVS Engineering and Construction challenged blocking of input tax credit before the Karnataka High Court (WP 16897/2026, 9 June 2026) after the department invoked Rule 86A alleging use of fake invoices without prior notice or prescribed procedure. Sections 169 and Rule 86A CGST Rules framed the dispute. Justice B.M. Shyam Prasad held the impugned blocking failed to conform to settled legal principles requiring notice and adherence to Rule 86A process before restricting electronic credit ledger entries. The blocking was quashed with direction to immediately unblock the ledger and permit fresh proceedings only in accordance with Rule 86A. Outcome favoured the assessee on procedural grounds. The case clarifies that ITC blocking is not a silent administrative step but must follow rule-based safeguards.

CGST S.169CGST Rules R.86A
High Court of TelanganaAppellate Authority

Gayathri Enterprises v. Joint Commissioner, Appeals-II

In favour of the revenue

Gayathri Enterprises challenged IGST demand on export supplies before the Telangana High Court (Writ Petition No. 8187 of 2026, 9 June 2026), alleging natural justice breaches and reliance on Notification 41/2017-IGST (Rate). The appellate authority had examined materials but found insufficient invoice-wise correlation. No jurisdictional error or mala fides was shown; Article 226 was declined under Sections 107 and 112 CGST in favour of GSTAT. Outcome favoured revenue on writ maintainability. Export IGST disputes with heavy fact-finding belong in the appellate chain, not writ, when prior orders are reasoned. This note is published for Chartered Universe GST case-law research and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the full order, confirm the decision date and citation, and assess whether later statutory changes affect reliance before advising clients or filing appeals.

CGST S.107CGST S.112Constitution Art.226
High Court of MadrasInterest Waiver

Zyvana Integrated Services (P.) Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner of GST and Central Excise

In favour of the assessee; matter remanded

Zyvana Integrated Services (P.) Ltd. filed W.P. No. 10854 of 2025 before the Madras High Court; decision 8 June 2026. The assessee disclosed outward supplies in GSTR-1 for certain tax periods but failed to discharge corresponding output tax in GSTR-3B within time. It cited delayed customer receipts and denied evasion intent. The court acknowledged statutory liability for short payment but, in light of Section 128A amnesty and GST Council deliberations, held such defaults warrant determination under Section 73 rather than the more stringent Section 74 track where appropriate. The impugned order was set aside and the matter remanded for fresh decision. Outcome: in favour of assessee with remand. Not legal advice. Classification between Sections 73 and 74 affects penalty exposure and amnesty, warranting careful framing of SCN allegations.

CGST S.128ACGST S.73CGST S.74